Continuing our notices of the prizes, awards, and fellowships announced at this year's meeting of the American Society for Legal History, we now turn to the winner of the William Nelson Cromwell Book Prize (awarded annually to the best book in the field of American legal history by an early career scholar):
Emilie Connolly, Vested Interests: Trusteeship and Native Dispossession in the United States (Princeton University Press, 2025).
Vested Interests: Trusteeship and Native Dispossession in the United States carefully and critically explains the trust and fiduciary processes that the U.S. federal government developed, haphazardly at first, from the early American period into the early twentieth century to finance Native dispossession but also to secure tribal dependence on federal trusteeship. With nuance and clarity, Connolly defines this process as “fiduciary colonialism,” a theoretical concept that will undoubtedly prove useful to historians seeking to explain the financial conditions that are integral to federal Indian policy and U.S.-tribal relations to this day. In addition to outlining the incremental developments of fiduciary colonialism, Connolly draws on close archival reading to incorporate the perspectives and influences of individual tribal leaders from the colonial era to the twentieth century. Helpful to readers outside the field of federal Indian policy and Native history, Connolly’s analysis features familiar state actors from George Washington and Alexander Hamilton to Harry Truman. The committee was especially impressed with the range and detail of historical coverage Connolly achieved in her study, which included multiple complex tribal histories linked to key moments of American history including the evolution of U.S. banking law and policy, the Civil War, the expansion of railroads and industrial infrastructure, and the expansion of U.S. empire. Connolly presented these intersecting and interdependent histories with remarkable narrative style and quality, inviting readers to fully grasp the painful ironies that Indigenous people encountered across the long nineteenth century while also documenting tribal leaders’ persistent challenges to dispossession and fraud.
-- Karen Tani