The 2026 election blue tsunami included women judges, most prominently, the Texas Supreme Court, which is now majority women. It joins 20 other states that boast female majorities. Yet in 8 states, there is only one woman on the highest state court. Overall, women are 43 percent of state supreme courts. Which still lags behind women’s proportion of the general population (51 percent), JD graduates (55 percent), and law students (56 percent).
| Ohio Supreme Court, 1932 courtesy of Bowling Green University Library, Center for Archival Collections |
A Long Time Coming
After Florence Allen was elected the nation’s first woman state supreme court judge in 1922 Ohio, it would take another 60 years until another woman was elected to that court. It was 40 years until a woman was elected to any state supreme court. A similar delay was seen on the federal court of decades after Allen’s appointment in 1934. I detail this in my new book, The First Woman Judge: The Life & Legacy of Florence Allen (UC Press 2026).
In the long run, Allen’s legacy won
out, but it was muted by the glacial pace of appointing women judges. . . .
The next woman appointed to the Sixth
Circuit, by President Jimmy Carter in 1979, twenty years after Allen’s
retirement, was conservative Michigan jurist Cornelia Kennedy, initially
nominated to the district court by President Richard Nixon. Judge Kennedy ruled
against women in a ban on coed sports, upheld the right of voters to restrict
civil rights for LGBTQ people, vacated Detroit school desegregation remedies,
ruled against Black plaintiffs in most race-based cases against the police or
prisons, and ruled against the plaintiff in a sexual harassment case, writing
that “civil rights law did not protect a woman from a boss’s obnoxious or
suggestive words.”
Beyond the Sixth Circuit, it would take
decades before Allen’s famous first triggered second and third appointments of
women. It would be sixty years, over half a century, before a woman was
appointed to the U.S. Supreme Court. It was not until 1981 that Ronald Reagan,
faced with a demonstrable gender gap, wooed women voters by making a campaign
promise to appoint the first woman Justice, which he did in nominating Sandra
Day O’Connor, an Arizona jurist and legislator. It would also take sixty years
before another woman served on the Ohio Supreme Court. Blanche Krupansky was
temporarily appointed by a Republican governor in 1981, and Alice Robie Resnick
was elected in 1989. It would be almost forty years after Allen’s first before
a woman served on the highest court of any state, with the ascension of Rhoda
Lewis in Hawaii and Lorna Lockwood in Arizona. And it would be thirty years
before a woman was appointed to any federal appellate court, as it was not
until 1968 that President Lyndon Johnson nominated Shirley Hufstedler to the
Ninth Circuit.
What ultimately triggered the shift then, if the advent of the first woman judge was not enough to open the judicial doors to women? At a basic level, it was the increase in the number of women lawyers, bringing not just more candidates, but more familiarity with and acceptance of women in these judicial roles. But more was needed.
As scholars have explained, although
token women like Allen “in a highly visible and powerful office may provide a
‘role model’ for women, they do not automatically trigger an increase in
appointments,” because tokenism can operate in the opposite way, restricting
rather than expanding opportunities due to the “mistaken belief that
inequality has been eradicated.” It
would take a systemic disruption to change this status quo and include women in
meaningful numbers. That disruption came at the federal level in the form of
President Carter’s 1977 executive order changing the process for nomination of
federal judges and prioritizing the recruitment of women and racial minorities.
The new process de-emphasized the practice of senators recommending political
candidates and created mandatory nominating commissions composed of diverse lawyers
and leaders, including women, to generate a merit-based list of candidates that
included certain numbers of women and people of color. First Woman Judge,
205.
Why Women Matter
Focusing on the pace and number of women judges raises the question of why electing women matters. Political scientist Sally Kenney, in her book, Gender & Justice: Why Women in the Judiciary Really Matter (Routledge 2013), explains the research and the theory of why it is in fact democratically important to have women judges. I placed this research into the specific context of Judge Allen:
[I]t is clear that gender and the
advent of the first woman judge made a “profound change in the status of women
and a radical departure in the conception and work of the courts.” Allen’s gender
made a tremendous difference in her symbolic role in shattering the glass
ceiling of the judiciary, thereby enhancing the legitimacy of the courts. She
was a powerful, nationally visible role model of “what a judge looks and sounds
like” for women, lawyers, judges, politicians, and the general public,
displaying how women could effectively govern in judicial roles. As Allen
explained, her breakthrough also empowered all women, for “when women sit in
government, women as a whole become conscious of their individual interest and
ownership in government.” Diversifying the bench to include women improved the
legitimacy of the courts by ending the systemic discrimination the law itself
created and enforced. As Allen said, since women are litigants, citizens, and
persons in the courts, “they are entitled to play their parts equally with men
in the administration of justice.” It is important, she said, that courts, as
defenders of the rule of law, not be seen as systems of exclusion and
oppression. Thus, it was justice simply to no longer exclude one-half of the
human race from judicial office.
Women on the bench also critically enhance the representational role of the courts as impartial tribunals by expanding the diversity of arbiters to include a broader portion of the polity. This representation functions to improve people’s trust in the decisions of the courts, with judges democratically reflecting the populace as a nonexclusionary body. Integrating the bench to include women makes for a “fairer legal system” beyond mere “window dressing or political correctness,” by more inclusively reflecting the norms of a wider and more representative community. Allen explained how women judges recalibrated the court’s structural impartiality by centering women’s experience and by negating stereotypes of women in the legal system that unfairly disadvantage litigants, witnesses, attorneys, and jurors. First Woman Judge, 204.
That it has taken more than a century to crawl towards this democratization
of courts, shows how radically transformative was the first woman judge.
--Tracy Thomas
















