Thursday, June 13, 2013

DeLombard, "In the Shadow of the Gallows"

We somehow missed this 2012 release from the University of Pennsylvania Press: In the Shadow of the Gallows: Race, Crime, and American Civic Identity, by Jeannine Marie DeLombard (University of Toronto). Here's the Press's description:
From Puritan Execution Day rituals to gangsta rap, the black criminal has been an enduring presence in American culture. To understand why, Jeannine Marie DeLombard insists, we must set aside the lenses of pathology and persecution and instead view the African American felon from the far more revealing perspectives of publicity and personhood. When the Supreme Court declared in Dred Scott that African Americans have "no rights which the white man was bound to respect," it overlooked the right to due process, which ensured that black offenders—even slaves—appeared as persons in the eyes of the law. In the familiar account of African Americans' historical shift "from plantation to prison," we have forgotten how, for a century before the Civil War, state punishment affirmed black political membership in the breach, while a thriving popular crime literature provided early America's best-known models of individual black selfhood. Before there was the slave narrative, there was the criminal confession.
Placing the black condemned at the forefront of the African American canon allows us to see how a later generation of enslaved activists—most notably, Frederick Douglass—could marshal the public presence and civic authority necessary to fashion themselves as eligible citizens. At the same time, in an era when abolitionists were charging Americans with the national crime of "manstealing," a racialized sense of culpability became equally central to white civic identity. What, for African Americans, is the legacy of a citizenship grounded in culpable personhood? For white Americans, must membership in a nation built on race slavery always betoken guilt? In the Shadow of the Gallows reads classics by J. Hector St. John de Crèvecoeur, Edgar Allan Poe, Frederick Douglass, Herman Melville, George Lippard, and Edward Everett Hale alongside execution sermons, criminal confessions, trial transcripts, philosophical treatises, and political polemics to address fundamental questions about race, responsibility, and American civic belonging.
A few blurbs:
"In her exquisitely written In the Shadow of the Gallows, Jeannine DeLombard reads early American criminal law in conjunction with the idea of social contract to illustrate the intricacies of political belonging from the early Republic through the antebellum period. Through the double helix of print and legal history, she chronicles the metamorphic role of authorship in African Americans' bids for enfranchisement against the backdrop of a nation entangled in contradictory definitions of personhood and property and of criminality and civility. Exemplary of humanities scholarship at its best, the book establishes the connections between American literature and the African American struggle for civic inclusion."—Priscilla Wald, Duke University
"I have long thought that DeLombard is at the absolute top of the scholars working on law and literature in North America, and In the Shadow of the Gallows confirms her status."—Alfred Brophy, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill
For more information, including the TOC, follow the link.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Conference: New World(s) of Faith: Religion and Law in Historical Perspective, 1500-2000

Today and tomorrow the University of Pennsylvania Law School hosts a mini-conference on "New World(s) of Faith: Religion and Law in Historical Perspective, 1500-2000." The event is co-sponsored by the University of Pennsylvania Department of History; the American Society for Legal History; the University of Michigan Law School; the University of Chicago Law School; the University of Minnesota Law School and Department of History; and the University of Illinois School of Law. Here's the line-up:

June 12:
Faith and Outsiders in Spanish America
Kif Augustine-Adams, Brigham Young University
Counting Chinese in a Catholic Country: The 1930 Mexican Census and Religious Difference

Orlando Rivero-Valdés, University of Pittsburgh
Afro-Cuban Religions and Brujería in Post-Colonial Cuba, 1898-1938

Commentators: TBA
Keynote Address and Reception
Dylan Penningroth, Northwestern UniversityFaith and Property in African American History 
June 13:
Faith and Freedom in Nineteenth Century United States
Abigail Cooper, University of Pennsylvania
“A Mere Form”: Marriage Rites and Lived Religion in the Refugee Camps of the American Civil War
Lucas Volkman, University of Missouri
Turmoils and Temporalities: The Slavery Question and Church Property Disputes in Missouri

Christopher Tomlins, University of California, Irvine
Debt, Death, and Redemption: Toward a Soterial-Legal History of the Turner Rebellion

Commentators: William Novak, University of Michigan
Faith and Citizenship in a Secular Polity
Winston Bowman, Brandeis University
A Civil Death: Mormon Disenfranchisement in the Mountain West

Kellen Funk, Princeton Univeristy
“This Stone Which I Erect Shall Be a House of God”: Disestablishment and Religious Corporations in New York, 1784-1854

Jeffrey Perry, Purdue University
“For the Peace of Society”: Baptist Church Discipline and Legalities in Early Kentucky

Commentators: Sarah Barringer Gordon, University of Pennsylvania
Faith and Government in Modern America
Kathleen Holscher, University of Minnesota
School Prayer, Bible Reading, and the Catholic Vocabulary of Religious Freedom in Mid-Century America

Ronit Stahl, University of Michigan
Basic Training: The Unintentional Consequences of the Education Requirements for Military Chaplains

Commentators: Barbara Young Welke, University of Minnesota

"The Virtues and Vices of Business—A Historical Perspective"

[Via Legal Scholarship Blog, we have the following announcement:]

The 2014 Business History Conference annual meeting will be held on March 13-15 in Frankfurt, Germany.  The Gesellschaft für Unternehmensgeschichte (GUG, Society for Business History) is handling local arrangements for the 2014 meeting. All sessions will take place at Goethe University in Frankfurt, and lodging will be in a number of area hotels.

The theme for the meeting will be "The Virtues and Vices of Business — A Historical Perspective." The organizers invite papers and session proposals that address both the micro and macro levels of the virtues and vices of business in historical perspective. In keeping with longstanding BHC policy, submissions need not be directly related to the conference theme. The 2014 Program Committee consists of: Ed Balleisen, Duke University (chair); Chris McKenna, University of Oxford; Andrea Schneider, Goethe University; Per Hansen, Copenhagen Business School (BHC President), and Jan-Otmar Hesse, University of Bielefeld. GUG members are encouraged to propose papers; the language of the conference will be English.

[From the Call for Papers:]

Is business good or bad, or both? Does business serve private or public interests, or both? A variety of theories from the social sciences furnish different answers to these questions and, by implication, different ideas about the role of the state in creating the good society. The 2014 BHC annual meeting aims to address these issues from a historical and empirical perspective by exploring the virtues and vices of business across societies from the early modern period to the present.

More.

June 2013 Issue of Reviews in American History

The June 2013 issue of Reviews in American History is out. Although full text is limited to subscribers, we'll spotlight some items of interest:
The Constitution Goes Public: Politics and the Ratification Debate -- Todd Estes (Oakland University) reviews Jürgen Heideking, The Constitution before the Judgment Seat: The Prehistory and Ratification of the American Constitution, 1787–1791 (John P. Kaminski and Richard Leffler, eds.) (University of Virginia Press, 2012).

The Inventor’s Dilemma—The Confederate Version -- William G. Thomas (University of Nebraska, Lincoln) reviews H. Jackson Knight, Confederate Invention: The Story of the Confederate States Patent Office and Its Inventors (Louisiana State University Press).

Social Reform through Social Exclusion --Thomas J. Humphrey (Cleveland State University) reviews Craig Calhoun, The Roots of Radicalism: Tradition, The Public Sphere, and Early Nineteenth-Century Social Movements (University of Chicago Press, 2012) and Michele Lise Tarter and Richard Bell, eds., Buried Lives: Incarcerated in Early America (University of Georgia Press, 2012).
Officers sans Army -- Erik S. Gellman (Roosevelt University) reviews Shawn Leigh Alexander, An Army of Lions: The Civil Rights Struggle Before the NAACP (Pennsylvania University Press, 2012).
The Many Faces of Judicial Independence -- Charles Zelden (Nova Southeastern University) reviews Jed Handelsman Shugerman, The People’s Courts: Pursuing Judicial Independence in America (Harvard University Press, 2012).

Trestman to Lecture on Bessie Margolin

Marlene Trestman, the author of the forthcoming book, Fair Labor: The Remarkable Life and Legal Career of Bessie Margolin, will deliver the Donald S. Shire Lecture at the U.S. Department of Labor, 200 Constitution Avenue, NW, Washington, DC, on Friday, June 28th, 2013.  The lecture, which is open to the public, will take place at 1:00 p.m. in the Department’s César Chávez Memorial Auditorium, which may be accessed via 3rd and C Streets, NW, entrance.  Please RSVP to Patricia Morgan at 202-693-5772 or Morgan.Patricia@dol.gov.

Tuesday, June 11, 2013

SEC Historical Society 2014 Writing Award

The SEC Historical Society announces a writing award on corporate governance for works that, while not necessarily historical, "incorporate at least one material from the collection of the [Society's] virtual museum and archive."  The recipient will receive a $5,000 prize at the Society’s June 2014 Annual Meeting program in Washington, D.C.

The winning essay "will be permanently added to Papers in the virtual museum and archive ... and linked within The Center for Audit Quality Gallery on Corporate Governance."  All applicants must complete and sign the writing award release. No submission will be considered without a completed and signed release. In the release, the applicant will attest that the essay is his/her own work, and is single-authored, confirm that the essay has never been published in any print or electronic format, and identify the material(s) in the virtual museum and archive used.  The essay must be in English, and must be a maximum of 3,000 words, inclusive of optional footnotes, bibliography or tables.

The competition is open to all who visit the Society’s website: “regulators from federal, state, municipal and international agencies; self-regulators; practitioners from corporations and law, accounting and auditing, and financial services firms; and academics – both professors and students.”  The jury will include “practitioners and professors of accounting and auditing, economics and law.”  Submission, by December 31, 2013, "is in hard copy by postal mail":

SEC Historical Society 2014 Writing Award
1101 Pennsylvania Avenue NW, Suite 600
Washington, D.C. 20004

The full guidelines and a release are here.

Schroeder Reviews Weiner's "Rule of the Clan"

Jeanne L. Schroeder, Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law, has posted Family Feud: Mark Weiner, The Rule of the Clan.  Here is the abstract:
In The Rule of the Clan, legal historian Mark Weiner confronts the paradox that freedom requires law. He takes aim at one common assumption of libertarian political theory: a strong state is a threat to individual freedom. He warns that nostalgia for earlier, simpler societies is a deluded fantasy.

Weiner examination of traditional societies throughout the world and across history show that they share a single broad organizational structure that belies their facial diversity: the clan. Within the clan, man, and even more strikingly, woman, is neither free nor an individual. She is subordinate to her function within the group – in the case of woman, reproduction. In the clan, there are no individual rights protected by law, only the honor of the extended family to be avenged by feud. Adopting the terminology of “founding father of legal history and legal anthropology, Henry Sumner Maine”, Weiner argues that individual rights only come into being with the development of the state when Status relations are superceded by Contract.

Surprisingly, in his defense of the classical liberal ideal of individual rights and equality, Weiner implicitly rejects one of liberalism’s founding propositions: a vision of the free individual in the state of nature. Weiner’s thesis is more consistent with the speculative tradition of Continental theory than with American liberalism.

Monday, June 10, 2013

Aaronson on Welfare Rights Lawyering in Reagan's California

Mark N. Aaronson, University of California Hastings College of the Law, has posted Representing the Poor: Legal Advocacy and Welfare Reform During Reagan's Gubernatorial Years, which appears in the Hastings Law Journal 64 (2013): 933-1119.  Here is the abstract:    
The empirical focus of this book-length work is the contentious political and legal battle over California welfare reform in the early 1970s. It is an extended, multifaceted case study of a kind not much found in the literature on social cause lawyering. The narrative highlights the forceful presence of Ronald Reagan and the pivotal role in representing the welfare poor carried out by Ralph Santiago Abascal, a government-funded legal aid attorney. To counter Reagan’s welfare policy ambitions, Abascal with other legal services lawyers, and in joint cause with recipient-led welfare rights organizations, relied on court litigation not in isolation but as part of an overall strategy that also involved legislative and administrative actions. Within the context of American pluralism and constitutionalism and from an analytical perspective, this study examines the professional and institutional character of group legal representation for the poor as a strategy for political empowerment and social change. While grounded in political and legal history, the study’s conceptual approaches primarily draw on ideas from political science and political theory about representation and from writings in legal ethics and legal education on professional role responsibilities. The principal thematic points are: (1) Social cause lawyering is a systemic necessity for the democratic and equitable functioning of our governing institutions; (2) the client constraints on the role of lawyers for groups or causes have more to do conceptually with understandings about the nature of representation than the applicability of ethical or procedural rules; and (3) the political consequences of such legal advocacy are variable and potentially contradictory.

June 2013 Journal of American History

The June 2013 issue of the Journal of American History is out. Here's a preview of the content (full text is limited to subscribers):

The House on Bayou Road: Atlantic Creole Networks in the Eighteenth and Nineteenth Centuries

Faubourg Tremé in New Orleans has been described as the oldest black neighborhood in America. In his article, Pierre Force uses as his starting point a dispute in 1813 over the payments for a house between a white man and a free man of color that took place in Tremé. Attempting to find out more about both parties to the case (won by the free man of color), Force reconstructs each man's family history and follows the archival track on a journey to Cuba, Haiti, France, Spain, and Senegal. What might have seemed at first sight like a random encounter between representatives of two different racial groups emerges as a story of shared ancestries and cultural references, as well as shifting allegiances and identities.

Status across Borders: Roger Taney, Black British Subjects, and a Diplomatic Antecedent to the Dred Scott Decision

Michael A. Schoeppner offers a fresh interpretation of the origins of then–attorney general Roger B. Taney’s 1832 opinion on the Negro Seamen Acts. Historians and legal scholars, many of them looking backward from the Supreme Court’s 1857 Dred Scott decision, have cited that opinion as Taney's first official examination of the racial limits of American citizenship. As a rule, however, they have not examined the history of the opinion itself. Inspired by recent work in transnational history, Schoeppner lays out that history and suggests that Taney’s primary purpose in writing the opinion had very little to do with African Americans. Rather, he argues, Taney was more concerned with limiting the international legal force of British imperial racial policies, and his use of history as a way of limiting the meaning of citizenship and subjecthood was a tactical response to British racial progressivism.

“Punishment of Mere Political Advocacy”: The FBI, Teamsters Local 544, and the Origins of the 1941 Smith Act Case

Donna T. Haverty-Stacke explores how the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s fear of fifth column infiltration and sabotage of the nation’s wartime preparedness program, along with the efforts of a grassroots working-class anticommunist movement in Minneapolis, led to the 1941 prosecution of twenty-nine Trotskyist antiwar activists and union leaders for advocating the overthrow of the U.S. government. Her article probes the World War II–era compromise certain Americans were willing to make between First Amendment rights and national security, and considers the consequences for organized labor, political dissent, and free speech. In so doing, this study provides a historical perspective on similar bargains struck today as America finds itself in a state of perpetual war on terror.
This issue also includes a "State of the Field" forum on American Environmental History:
Since the Journal of American History last published a round table on the subject in 1990, American environmental history has seen explosive growth. Paul S. Sutter takes us on a selective tour of this expansive field, paying particular attention to questions of environmental causation and the ways environmental historians have replaced the once-firm categories of nature and culture with various approaches to environmental hybridity. That hybrid turn, Sutter suggests, has been analytically essential, yet it has also left the field at a moral crossroads. Following Sutter’s essay David Igler, Christof Mauch, Gregg Mitman, Linda Nash, Helen M. Rozwadowski, and Bron Taylor offer critical responses.
For more of the TOC, including exhibition and book reviews, follow the link.

Sunday, June 9, 2013

Kens on Bernstein on Lochner


In lieu of a Sunday book review post, I’ll just note my appreciation of The History and Implications of Lochner v. New York, Paul Kens’s review for H-Law of David E. Bernstein’s Rehabilitating Lochner: Defending Individual Rights against Progressive Reform.  I thought Professor Kens avoided the many pitfalls that await the reviewer of a book on a topic that the reviewer has already addressed at book length.  By giving Rehabilitating Lochner the respect it deserves, even as he pointed out his disagreements with it, he has made it easier for the rest of us to make up our own minds about the interpretations he and Professor Bernstein offer of a landmark of American constitutional history.

Saturday, June 8, 2013

Weekend Roundup

Image credit
  • The Spring 2013 issue of the Green Bag is out. LHB readers may be particularly interested in G. Edward White's piece on "the ALI's recent history and current challenges." 
  • Back in April, Kurt Newman (Ph.D. candidate, University of California, Santa Barbara) wrote a series of posts for the U.S. Intellectual History Blog on “Pragmatism and the Class Politics of Oliver Wendell Holmes, Jr.’s Copyright Jurisprudence.” Check it out here.
  • From the Canadian Legal History Blog: an announcement of this year's article and book prize winners from the Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History.
The Weekend Roundup is a weekly feature compiled by all the Legal History bloggers.

Friday, June 7, 2013

Kluge Fellowships at the Library of Congress

[We have the following announcement.  Recent fellows Kluge Fellows include the legal historians Emily Kadens and Risa Goluboff.]

The John W. Kluge Center at the Library of Congress is now accepting applications for Kluge Fellowships. The application deadline is July 15, 2013.

The Kluge Fellowships are residential research fellowships at the Library of Congress open to scholars worldwide with a Ph.D. or other terminal advanced degree conferred within seven years of the deadline. The Fellowship supports research in the humanities and social sciences, especially interdisciplinary, cross-cultural or multilingual projects. The Kluge Center especially encourages humanistic and social science research that makes use of the Library’s large and varied collections.

Fellowships are tenable for periods from four to eleven months at a stipend of $4,200 per month. Up to ten Kluge Fellowships will be awarded. Fellows may be in residence at any time during the fourteen-month window between June 1 of the year in which the Fellowship is awarded and August 1 of the year following. The constraints of space and the desirability of accommodating the maximum number of fellows may lead to an offer of fewer months than originally requested.  Apply for the Kluge Fellowship here. 

The John W. Kluge Center was established at the Library of Congress in 2000 to foster a mutually enriching relationship between the world of ideas and the world of action, between scholars and political leaders. The Center attracts outstanding scholarly figures to Washington, D.C., facilitates their access to the Library’s remarkable collections, and helps them engage in conversation with policymakers and the public. Learn more here.

Ziegler's Legal History of "Originalism Talk"

Mary Ziegler, Florida State University College of Law, has posted Originalism Talk: A Legal History.  Here is the abstract:
Progressives have long recognized the tremendous political appeal of originalism: it achieves results consistent with conservative values but promises the public judicial neutrality. By drawing on new historical research on antiabortion constitutionalism, this Article argues for a radically different understanding of the originalist ascendancy. Contrary to what we often think, conservative social movements at times made significant sacrifices in joining an originalist coalition. These costs were built in to what this Article calls originalism talk — the use of arguments, terms, and objectives associated with conservative originalism.

Scholars have documented the costs confronted by social movements reliant on rights-based rhetoric, particularly when activists seek social change in the courts. Originalism talk was similarly constraining. By becoming part of an originalist coalition, abortion opponents increased their influence over the selection of federal judicial nominees. At the same time, in stressing originalist rhetoric, abortion opponents had to set aside longstanding constitutional commitments involving the right to life, the personhood of the fetus, and the existence of rights based in natural law or human-rights principles.

The story of antiabortion constitutionalism offers insight into progressive attempts to create a doctrinally satisfying and politically resonant alternative to conservative originalism. Often, the issue is how to create an interpretive method that accomplishes as much as originalism: advancing progressive constitutional beliefs while appealing to the public’s interest in the rule of law. As this Article shows, however, it is not clear that the benefits of belonging to the originalist coalition outweigh its costs.

Metzger on "Administrative Constitutionalism"

Although it sounds more in administrative law than constitutional history, because of Jerry L. Mashaw’s Creating the Administrative Constitution: The Lost One Hundred Years of Administrative Law (Yale University Press, 2012) and the articles (e.g., here and here) and forthcoming book (The Workplace Constitution from the New Deal to the New Right [Cambridge University Press, 2014]) of Sophia Z. Lee (Penn Law), Gillian Metzger’s recently posted Administrative Constitutionalism ought to be noticed here.  (Metzger's article is forthcoming in the Texas Law Review 91 [June 2013].)  Here is the abstract:
Administrative constitutionalism is increasingly becoming a central subject of study. Administrative constitutionalism includes not just the application of established constitutional requirements by administrative agencies, but in addition the elaboration of new constitutional understandings by administrative actors and the construction of the administrative state. This attention to administrative constitutionalism is overdue, as it represents a main mechanism by which constitutional meaning is elaborated and implemented today. But recently offered examples of administrative constitutionalism are notably divergent, suggesting a need for some exegesis of administrative constitutionalism's different dimensions.

Identifying administrative constitutionalism's various forms highlights the challenges confronting it as a form of constitutional interpretation. Central to these is a legitimacy dilemma: What justifies administrative efforts to move the nation beyond recognized constitutional requirements to develop new constitutional understandings, especially if doing so means pushing at the limits of agencies' delegated authority and acting in ways not initiated by political leaders? In this Essay, I argue that administrative constitutionalism in fact represents a particularly legitimate and beneficial form of constitutional development. But the accountability challenges it poses are real, particularly given the frequent difficulty involved in identifying instances of administrative constitutionalism in action. Agencies' constitutional engagement occurs in the context of implementing programs and enforcing statutes, and often agencies do not expressly engage with the constitutional dimensions of their actions - indeed, these dimensions may only become apparent over time. Similarly, courts are rarely open about the constitutional or law-creative aspects of their development of administrative law. Given administrative constitutionalism's attenuated democratic accountability, greater transparency about this method of constitutional development is essential for its legitimacy.

Hoyos reviews Brooks & Rose, "Saving the Neighborhood"

From JOTWELL's Legal History Section: Roman Hoyos (Southwestern Law School) reviews Richard R.W. Brooks and Carol M. Rose, Saving the Neighborhood: Racially Restrictive Covenants, Law, and Social Norms (Harvard University Press, 2013). Here's the first paragraph of the review:
One of my favorite cases is Shelley v. Kraemer (1948), which held that racially restrictive covenants (restrictions barring a racial or ethnic group(s) from owning a home in a particular neighborhood) were unenforceable. In fact, I use this case, along with State v. Mann, Commonwealth v. Alger, and Johnson v. M’Intosh, to help frame my Property course. I use Alger and Johnson to get my students to think about the statist dimensions of property. I then bring in Shelley to explore the relationship between courts and the state, pushing them to see how a judicial decision concerning property rights is an allocation of those rights by the state. Richard Brooks and Carol Rose’s book, Saving the Neighborhood, is a wonderful doctrinal history of Shelley that both confirms and complicates the story I tell my students. More importantly for this piece, it also complicates our understanding of an important period in American legal history.
Read on here.

Thursday, June 6, 2013

Orren and Walker on Paths Not Taken in Marbury

[We've just learned that this article is now available ungated on SSRN.]

We don’t always post on gated articles, but this one looks interesting.  Karen Orren and Christopher Walker, University of California, Los Angeles, have posted an abstract for Cold Case File: Indictable Acts and Officer Accountability in Marbury v. Madison, which appears in the American Political Science Review 107 (May 2013): 241-59.  Here it is:
William Marbury (credit)
Starting from the position that officer accountability is a core value of American constitutionalism, this article reassesses Marbury v. Madison in light of the indictable acts connected to the nondelivery of Marbury’s commission. First, it reads Chief Justice Marshall’s opinion against the background of personal and political hostility among the principals, including between Marbury and President Jefferson. Second, it identifies avenues of further redress open to Marbury before and after the Supreme Court’s refusal of the mandamus order, and it considers why they were not pursued. Finally, having identified alternative procedural traditions on which Marshall could have drawn, and reviewed decisions by state and federal judges in analogous suits against officers, it concludes that Marbury’s deepest contribution was to elevate the principle of jurisdiction over the imperative of remedy in constitutional decision making.

ASLH Miami 2013

Just a heads up that the site of this year's annual meeting, the Hyatt Regency Miami, is taking reservations at the conference rate.  (The meeting is November 7-10.)  According to the ASLH's website:
For the first time in its history, the Society will be hosting its annual meeting in South Florida. The conference hotel is the Hyatt Regency Miami. Most of the events will be physically in Miami, but we will repair to Fort Lauderdale for the plenary and the reception, where we will be the guests of Nova Southestern University Farquhar College of Arts and Sciences.

University of Western Australia Seeks Professor of Law & Society

The University of Western Australia has announced this job opening, among others: 

ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR/PROFESSOR IN LAW AND SOCIETY
As a result of its successful introduction of a new BA Major in Law and Society in 2012, The University of Western Australia Law School is seeking to appoint an academic with interests in socio-legal studies/law and society/empirical studies in law.
Applicants must have a PhD or equivalent in research. Applicants with teaching experience are requested to submit a teaching portfolio as part of their application if they are tempted by a beautiful city, warmer weather, a strong economy, high achieving students, and a collegial atmosphere within a research-intensive university, ranked in the World's top-100.
More information is available here.

Hat tip: Felicity Turner

Wesson, "A Death at Crooked Creek"

As Dan mentioned in the last Weekend Roundup, the Spring 2013 edition of H-Law's "New Books in U.S. Constitutional/Legal History" is now out. (We owe a big thanks to Timothy S. Huebner, Rhodes College, for the yeoman service of compiling the list.) One title that caught my eye was Marianne Wesson's A Death at Crooked Creek: The Case of the Cowboy, the Cigarmaker, and the Love Letter (New York University Press, 2013). Intrigued, I looked up a fuller description. Here it is:

One winter night in 1879, at a lonely Kansas campsite near Crooked Creek, a man was shot to death. The dead man’s traveling companion identified him as John Hillmon, a cowboy from Lawrence who had been attempting to carve out a life on the blustery prairie. The case might have been soon forgotten and the apparent widow, Sallie Hillmon, left to mourn—except for the $25,000 life insurance policies Hillmon had taken out shortly before his departure. The insurance companies refused to pay on the policies, claiming that the dead man was not John Hillmon, and Sallie was forced to take them to court in a case that would reach the Supreme Court twice. The companies’ case rested on a crucial piece of evidence: a faded love letter written by a disappeared cigarmaker, declaring his intent to travel westward with a “man named Hillmon.”

In A Death at Crooked Creek, Marianne Wesson re-examines the long-neglected evidence in the case of the Kansas cowboy and his wife, recreating the court scenes that led to a significant Supreme Court ruling on the admissibility of hearsay evidence. Wesson employs modern forensic methods to examine the body of the dead man, attempting to determine his true identity and finally put this fascinating mystery to rest.

This engaging and vividly imagined work combines the drama, intrigue, and emotion of excellent storytelling with cutting-edge forensic investigation techniques and legal theory. Wesson’s superbly imagined A Death at Crooked Creek will have general readers, history buffs, and legal scholars alike wondering whether history, and the Justices, may have misunderstood altogether the events at that bleak winter campsite.
For more information, including access to the book's Introduction, follow the link.

Turner to Armstrong Atlantic State

Congratulations to Felicity Turner, who will join the Armstrong Atlantic State University Department of History this fall as a tenure-track assistant professor. She is currently completing her stint as a Jerome Hall Post-doctoral Fellow at Indiana University, Bloomington. Cribbing now from the IU website:
Image credit
Felicity Turner's research uses narratives of infanticide as recorded in newspapers, inquests, and court cases to trace changes in conceptions of gender, race, and the human body in the nineteenth-century United States. During her tenure as a Jerome Hall fellow, she will continue work on her manuscript-in-progress, "Narratives of Infanticide: Mothers, Murder, and the State in Nineteenth-Century America." Felicity's dissertation, upon which the manuscript is based, received an Honorable Mention from the Law and Society Association Dissertation Prize Committee in June 2011.
Turner received her PhD in history from Duke University in 2010. Her research has been supported by fellowships from the Newberry Library, the William Nelson Cromwell Foundation, and an Albert J. Beveridge Grant from the American Historical Association. During 2010-2011, Felicity was a postdoctoral fellow at the United States Studies Centre at the University of Sydney, Australia. During the 2011-2012 academic year, she was the Law and Society Postdoctoral Fellow at the University of Wisconsin Law School. In June 2011, Felicity also participated in the 2011 Hurst Summer Institute in Legal History, a biennial event hosted by the Institute for Legal Studies at the UW Law School and cosponsored by the American Society for Legal History.

Wednesday, June 5, 2013

Stealey's "West Virginia Civil War Era Constitution"

John E. Stealey, III, distinguished professor emeritus of history at Shepherd University, has published  West Virginia’s Civil War Era Constitution: Loyal Revolution, Confederate Counter-Revolution, and the Convention of 1872 with the Kent State University Press:
When western Virginians separated from the Commonwealth of Virginia to form West Virginia, the distinctive action reflected five decades of deep dissatisfaction with the Commonwealth’s regressive constitution and the governmental procedures that protected slavery. The westerners’ creation of a new state was revolutionary in the context of U. S. statecraft. New constitutional approaches and laws addressed past wrongs and the realities of war. Grave external and internal forces, sometimes armed, opposed West Virginia’s creation and establishment of civil order and state institutions.

The state-makers resorted to statutory and constitutional measures, often arbitrarily applied, to preserve the state, their legislation, and their political position. Some enactments removed state citizenship and the franchise from the disloyal; enabled the seizure of rebel property; required oaths of past loyalty for voting, suing in courts, and for the practice of professions such as teaching, law, and other pursuits; and established a stringent registration system administered by the loyal to prospective voters. Returning Confederates, along with stay-at-home sympathizers, and opponents of national policies organized a political and legal assault that succeeded.

Rejecting the hackneyed and inaccurate concept of “Reconstruction” as it reflects rebel assertions, author John Stealey reinterprets West Virginia’s post–Civil War constitutional and political development within the counter-revolutionary framework. The Democratic/Conservative opponents of the Republican state-makers rode to power after seven years on the issues of race and the existence of wartime and postwar statutory and constitutional enactments that assured temporary state security and political dominance of the loyal. The torturous and complicated path to counter-revolutionary success and change occurred within the context of national events.

A primary counter-revolutionary goal was drafting a new constitution to replace the state-makers’ original of 1861–1863. The Constitutional Convention of 1872 was the culmination of the quest for power. Stealey presents for the first time a comprehensive account of the debates and acts of the constitutional convention that reflected the Virginia and wartime experiences of delegates as well as the counter-revolutionary aims of the overwhelming Democratic/Conservative majority. This framework still serves as the Mountain State’s fundamental law.
A review in the Charleston Gazette is here; an interview with Professor Stealey on West Virginia Public Broadcasting is here.

McAward on McCulloch and the Thirteenth Amendment

Jennifer Mason McAward, Notre Dame Law School, has posted McCulloch and the Thirteenth Amendment, which appeared in the Columbia Law Review 112 (2012).  Here is the abstract:
Section 2 of the Thirteenth Amendment gives Congress the “power to enforce” the ban on slavery and involuntary servitude “by appropriate legislation.” The conventional view of Section 2 regards this language as an allusion to McCulloch v. Maryland’s explication of Congress’s executory powers, and holds that Congress has substantial, and largely unreviewable, power to determine both the ends and the means of Section 2 legislation.

This Essay argues that the conventional view departs from the original meaning of Section 2. It demonstrates that McCulloch preserved a role for judicial review with respect to both the ends and means of federal legislation. This role was clearly part of the understanding and anticipated application of McCulloch by the time the Thirteenth Amendment was ratified and the Civil Rights Act of 1866 enacted. This Essay concludes that Section 2 preserves a role for meaningful judicial review and grants Congress power to regulate conduct that threatens the reinvigoration of slavery or involuntary servitude, but not near-plenary power over all civil or human rights.

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Szalai's "Outsourcing Justice"

Imre Szalai, Loyola University New Orleans College of Law, has just published Outsourcing Justice: The Rise of Modern Arbitration Laws in America, with the Carolina Academic Press:
Arbitration is a method of dispute resolution in which parties agree to submit their dispute to a private, neutral third person, instead of a traditional court with a judge and jury. This private system of arbitration, which is often confidential and secretive, can be a polar opposite, in almost every way, to the public court system.

Over the past few decades, arbitration agreements have proliferated throughout American society. Such agreements appear in virtually all types of consumer transactions, and millions of American workers are bound by arbitration agreements in their employment relationships. America has become an “arbitration nation,” with an increasing number of disputes taken away from the traditional, open court system and relegated to a private, secretive system of justice. How did arbitration agreements become so widespread, and enforceable, in American society? Prior to the 1920s, courts generally refused to enforce such agreements, and parties had the right to bring their disputes to court. However, during the 1920s, Congress and state legislatures suddenly enacted ground-breaking laws declaring that arbitration agreements are “valid, irrevocable, and enforceable.”

Drawing on previously untapped archival sources, this book explores the many different people, institutions, forces, beliefs, and events that led to the enactment of modern arbitration laws during the 1920s, and this book examines why America’s arbitration laws radically changed during this period. By examining this history, this book demonstrates how the U.S. Supreme Court has grossly misconstrued these laws and unjustifiably created an expansive, informal, private system of justice touching almost every aspect of American society and impacting the lives of millions.
A detailed table of contents is here.

LSA Stanton Wheeler Mentorship Award to Friedman

Congratulations to Lawrence Friedman (Stanford University)! The Law & Society Association has named him the winner of this year's Stanton Wheeler Mentorship award. Here's the citation:
Image credit
Lawrence M. Friedman has served as a beloved mentor to generations of students, colleagues, and scholars in the law and society tradition. Teaching over many years in a law school environment, he has educated and inspired not only his JD students but also undergraduate students and students in other graduate programs and professional schools. Students from outside the United States benefited from the international legal studies programs that Lawrence has helped to sustain. Colleagues near and far regard him as a model of “first-rate citizenship and institution-building for the profession at large.”
Lawrence Friedman’s mentorship goes well beyond inspiring others by outstanding teaching and brilliant and prolific scholarship. Many nominators wrote movingly of the way in which Lawrence Friedman took deep interest in their personal well-being and professional development. He offered trenchant advice and unflagging support that transformed their lives.
  • “I may not have found my place in legal education at all, but for Lawrence’s insightful tutelage and sheer tenacity in laboring long term as my mentor.”
  • “He believed in my potential as a scholar, perhaps even more than I did myself.”
  • “Without Lawrence’s support for my research and teaching ambitions, I truly do not know whether I would have been able to pursue the path that I have to this day.”
  • “His influence and his example impressed upon me the importance of doing everything I can to mentor my own students.”
For his outstanding mentorship of law and society scholars, Lawrence Friedman richly deserves the Stan Wheeler Mentorship Award.

LSA John Hope Franklin Prize to Ferrer

Credit
Ada Ferrer (New York University) is the recipient of the 2013 John Hope Franklin Prize (in recognition of "exceptional scholarship in the field of Race, Racism and the Law") from the Law & Society Association for her article "Haiti, Free Soil, and Antislavery in the Revolutionary Atlantic." It appeared in Volume 117 of the American Historical Review (2012). Here's the citation:
In her article Haiti, Free Soil, and Antislavery in the Revolutionary Atlantic, Ada Ferrer provides an excellent example of how Haitian legal institutions and principles influenced the Atlantic world, including discussions of human rights and emancipation. Specifically, Ferrer presents a case study in the application of the Haitian Republic’s Constitution of 1816 to create a safe-haven territory to which slaves and even free blacks could escape or migrate with the expectation of living as free people, and she traces the effect of this law, and more generally the Haitian Revolution, on the slave societies that surrounded Haiti in the Caribbean and Atlantic, and even the effect of these factors in Europe, the United States and South America.

Monday, June 3, 2013

The Backhouse Backlist

[We're moving up this updated post.]

Constance B. Backhouse, a Distinguished University Professor on the University of Ottawa's Faculty of Law and an immediate Past President of the ASLH, has posted some of her backlist:

"Pleasing Appearance...Only Adds to the Danger": The 1930 Insanity Hearing of Violet Hypatia Bowyer, Canadian Journal of Women and the Law 17:1 (2005) 1-13
The state's legal authority to detain individuals within insane asylums in early twentieth-century Canada was deeply influenced by factors of gender, class, and race. Violet Hypatia Bowyer, a working-class, white woman who was just twenty-two years old in 1928, was initially incarcerated in Ontario for leading a 'dissolute' life. Wrongly diagnosed as 'insane' by prison officials, she tried valiantly, but failed, to secure her release through legal challenge. The expert testimony of the prison officials, the psychiatric 'experts,' and the decision of the court all testify to the terrifying coerciveness of law in Canadian history.
'Don't You Bully Me - Justice I Want If There is Justice to Be Had': The Rape of Mary Ann Burton, London, Ontario, 1907, in People and Place: Historical Influences on Legal Culture, ed. Jonathan Swainger and Constance Backhouse (Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press, 2003), 60-94.
In 1907, Mary Ann Burton launched a complaint of rape against Joseph Gray in London, Ontario. Judicial decisions and literature at the time claimed that rape was “an accusation easily to be made”, despite the common knowledge that rape was underreported. Mary Ann Burton's case sets no legal precedent; she was treated with suspicion and hostility, and the charges were ultimately dismissed by the court. Yet Mrs. Burton resisted the antagonism she experienced – namely tactics by defence counsel to attack her character, her image as a “worthy victim”, her credibility, and her recollection of every finite detail of the incident. She remained resolute in her testimony and her right to be protected from rape, in the face of pernicious commentary from acquaintances, and a courtroom that systematically discredited and ultimately dismissed her based largely on her gender and class.
The Doctrine of Corroboration in Sexual Assault Trials in Early Twentieth-Century Canada and Australia, Queen's Law Journal 26 (2001): 297-338.
The author compares two early twentieth century criminal cases, one Australian and one Canadian, involving carnal knowledge of a child. The cases illustrate the parallel development of the doctrine of corroboration in sexual assault cases in the two countries – a doctrine which was based on the belief that the testimony of women and girls in such cases was inherently suspect. By requiring that corroborating evidence be independent of the complainant's testimony, and by interpreting that requirement in an extremely rigid way to exclude particular items of evidence that strongly supported the complaints, the courts in both cases imposed unjustified obstacles to the conviction of men accused of sexual offences. This misuse of the doctrine of corroboration contradicted the ideals of evenhanded justice and gender equality in both Canada and Australia.
'I Was Unable to Identify with Topsy' - Carrie M. Best's Struggle Against Racial Segregation in Nova Scotia, 1942, Atlantis 22 (Spring 1998) 16-26.
This paper describes a court case that was buried in Canadian legal archives for fifty-six years. In 1942, Carrie Best brought a civil action for damages against a Nova Scotia theatre, claiming that the owners were enforcing a racially-segregated seating policy. The action was ultimately dismissed. Dr. Best, an African-Canadian who was a teacher, journalist, and founder of The Clarion (a newspaper that she began publishing in 1945) had been a long-time advocate for human rights and activist against racial discrimination and segregation in Nova Scotia. Carrie Best's decorated career as a journal and activist is public knowledge, but the history of her unsuccessful litigation calls for scrutiny. Such cases help us understand Canadian history to be deeply marked with racism. 

Grossman on the FDA and the Rise of the Empowered Consumer

Lewis A. Grossman, American University, Washington College of Law, has posted FDA and the Rise of the Empowered Consumer.  Here is the abstract:
This paper traces the historical evolution of a view of consumers as informed, rational, and rights-bearing decision makers, and the corresponding diminution of FDA’s role as a paternalistic gatekeeper acting in conjunction with medical and scientific experts to prevent products and information from reaching the public.

The relationship between consumers and FDA-regulated products has changed dramatically since the mid-1960s. A half century ago, FDA treated consumers as passive and ignorant. Accordingly, the agency gave them relatively little latitude to make their own choices among products and denied them much of the information they could have used to inform such choices. By comparison, today’s consumers of food and drugs are much more empowered to make their own, unmediated choices among a wider variety of products, guided by a deluge of labeling and advertising information.

The paper examines this phenomenon against a background of three societal and cultural trends during the past half century: Americans’ declining trust in major institutions, the “rights revolution,” and the dramatic expansion of health care information accessible to consumers. It then examines a variety of specific regulatory developments during this period of change. In a section on food, the paper considers reforms in standards of identity and nutrition labeling, the rise of health claims as facilitated by the First Amendment, and various popular movements for freedom of choice with respect to food ingredients and dietary supplements. The paper then turns to drug regulation, examining the rise of patient labeling and direct-to-consumer advertising of prescription drugs, the tidal wave of “switches” from prescription to over-the-counter status, and the birth of social movements seeking to influence FDA drug approval policy. The paper concludes by speculating on whether this new model of consumer is a permanent one.

Tracking Down Oral Histories on Regulation

[We have the following query about what looks to be a very useful project. My suggestion is the Oral History Program of the Historical Society of the D.C. Circuit.]

At Duke University, history professor Ed Balleisen is leading a project to create an online gateway to regulatory oral histories—oral histories with regulators, the regulated, or political actors who were instrumental in creating or changing regulatory agencies or frameworks. As part of the project, we are working to catalog and tag the most relevant oral histories to make them more accessible as well as to help sort through what interviews have been conducted and the work that remains to be done. We have identified several caches, such as those at the SEC Historical Society and the Columbia Center for Oral History (e.g. its FCC project), but we hope to draw on the knowledge of the blog's readers to target individual interviews or other rich collections of oral histories regarding regulatory agencies, whether in the U.S. or elsewhere, at any level of government. While we're especially interested in creating an extant database of digitally accessible oral histories, do also let us know if you're aware of relevant oral histories that remain in analog without a digital transcript. Please e-mail any tips, leads, or general thoughts on the project to william.goldsmith@duke.edu, and much obliged.

LSA Hurst Prize to Witt, "Lincoln's Code"

Congratulations to John Fabian Witt (Yale Law School): The Law & Society Association has named Lincoln's Code (the Free Press) the winner of this year's J. Willard Hurst award ("given to the best work (in English) in socio-legal history published in the previous year"). Here's the citation:
Image credit
John Witt's Lincoln's Code is a tour de force of legal history.  Its sweeping narrative of the origins of the modern law of war carries us from the battlefields of the American Revolution, through Indian Removal, to the carnage of Sherman's march and Gettysburg.  At the center of the narrative is a legal code, the set of rules for wartime commissioned by Abraham Lincoln and written by Francis Lieber, that is still the basis for the laws of war.  Witt demonstrates the way statesmen, soldiers, and lawyers struggled with the competing aims of humanitarianism and justice, and the way Lieber's code constrained some aspects of inhumanity in battle, yet allowed mass destruction in the name of a just cause.  And he shows how slavery shaped the laws of war:  the protection of slave property had been seen as a chief humanitarian accomplishment during the Revolution, but during the Civil War, the military imperative of emancipation helped to establish the primacy of justice over humanitarianism in Lieber's code.  In doing so, it gave the U.S. Civil War a global significance it otherwise might not have had. 
Weaving together deep archival research, compelling biography, incisive legal analysis, and entertaining storytelling, Lincoln's Code is a groundbreaking, original history with enduring significance for our times.  John Witt has pushed the boundaries of traditional sociolegal history and given us a new way to think about the history of war, with law at its troubled center. It will endure as a touchstone in the field, both for its nimble navigation of source material and its sheer interpretive force. Lincoln’s Code is a model of scholarly work that is both firmly grounded in historical analysis and profoundly relevant to the contemporary world.
Honorable mentions went to Ken Mack (Harvard Law School) for Representing the Race: The Creation of the Civil Rights Lawyer (Harvard University Press) and Michele Landis Dauber (Stanford Law School) for The Sympathetic State: Disaster Relief and the Origins of the American Welfare State (University Of Chicago Press).

Sunday, June 2, 2013

Weekend Roundup

  • We Legal History Bloggers are grateful to Joanna Grisinger, Northwestern Legal Studies, for organizing so many legal history panels at the just-concluded annual meeting of the Law and Society Association.  Thanks, Joanna!
  • Via H-Law, we have news of a new exhibit at the Harvard Law School Library, Research Revealed: Six Scholars Explore Historical & Special Collections.  “This exhibit celebrates the relationship between the staff of the Library's Historical & Special Collection and the scholars who visit us to use our collections. It is on view weekdays 9 to 5 in the Caspersen Room, Langdell Hall, through August 9, 2013.”
  • Not only do the Illuminati exist; they read legal history.  Check out the comments to this Jotwell post.  Hat tip: Richard Ross.
  • Hat tip to Michael Widener, Yale Law,  for spotting in The Scout Report, May 31, 2013, the notice "Maps of Private Land Grant Cases of California” and sending the link.  From the Scout Report: “This remarkable collection from the Bancroft Library collects maps that supported private land claim cases from 1850 to approximately 1890. Visitors should first look over the collection's finding aid, which is available in several formats. In total, there are over 1,400 maps here, some of which are exquisitely hand-colored. It's a fascinating way to learn about legal history, geography, and the complex interactions between the United States government and the newly formed U.S. District Courts of California. [KMG]"
  • The latest issue of the Ohio Northern University Law Review has reviews of Scott Douglas Gerber, A Distinct Judicial Power: The Origins of an Independent Judiciary, 1606-1787 (Oxford University Press, 2011), by Stephen Presser and Charles A. Kromkowski. 
Weekend Roundup is a weekly feature compiled by all the Legal History bloggers.

Saturday, June 1, 2013

CFP: Edited Collection on "Arrested Development"

Today I out myself as a big fan of Arrested Development -- because I am going to post this CFP:
Over the course of its original three-year run on Fox, the television series Arrested Development quickly became a cult favorite and earned twenty-two Emmy nominations and six wins, including Outstanding Comedy Series in 2004. Unafraid to push boundaries, the series routinely satirized issues of race, sexuality, family, love, politics, and class, to name only a few. Combined with its sophisticated writing and its perfectly cast group of series regulars, the show became a layered and intricate look into modern society and one of the funniest sitcoms to emerge in the last decade. With this in mind, Dr. Kristin M. Barton is seeking proposals for an edited volume under consideration at McFarland which will explore Arrested Development from a scholarly perspective.
For more info, follow the link. (Hat tip: H-Law)

I would love to see some legal historians get in on this action. I've even thought of some potential topics:
"When Marrying Your Cousin Became a Crime" (on the legal-historical antecedents of the (seemingly) ill-fated love of George Michael and Maeby).
"From the Cornballer to the Magic Coffin" (Arrested Development as a window onto the evolution of products liability law in the late twentieth century).
"Law and the Conditions of George Bluth's Freedom" (a comparison of Willard Hurst's Pike Creek squatters to the notorious squatters in the Bluth company's model home).
"Does the SEC Really Have Police Boats?" (a history of SEC enforcement tactics - which will surely include this quote, from former SEC commissioner Paul S. Atkins: "We don’t carry guns; we have no boats . . . We do not even have authority to arrest people.").
Any takers?