Wednesday, November 18, 2026

ASLH John Phillip Reid Book Award to Lew-Williams

Continuing our notices of the prizes, awards, and fellowships given out at this year's meeting of the American Society for Legal History, we now turn to the winner of the John Phillip Reid Book Award ("awarded annually for the best monograph by a mid-career or senior scholar, published in English in any of the fields defined broadly as Anglo-American legal history"):

Beth Lew-Williams, John Doe, Chinaman: A Forgotten History of Chinese Life under American Racial Law (Belknap/Harvard University Press).

Lew-Williams offers a revelatory, kaleidoscopic, and engrossing analysis of how Chinese immigrants and Chinese Americans on the West Coast endured, challenged, and maneuvered around thousands of anti-Chinese laws from the 1850s to the 1920s. Contesting the dominant historiographical frame of exclusion, she focuses on the changing legal modes of “conditional inclusion.” While their labor was in demand, and while they held basic civil rights from 1870 on, the Chinese faced discrimination in myriad ways in economic, residential, cultural, and political terrains. From the outset, they launched lawsuits, submitted petitions, and organized resistance to racialized enforcement. Their efforts rewrote the most damaging terms of their inclusion and put limits on the metastasizing form of white supremacy “tailored just for them.”
 
The book models how to do legal history that integrates all manner of court records, state and federal legislation, city ordinances, police records, business ledgers, media accounts, memoirs, and more. Much of the extensive research rests on difficult-to-access archives across three states—California, Oregon, and Washington. The book is brilliantly organized and hard-to-put-down, with each chapter anchored by vivid and often-unfamiliar stories and voices from Chinese Westerners of all ages. Perhaps most haunting are the inescapable instances of white record-keepers who disregarded individuals’ true names in favor of demeaning placeholders such as ‘John Doe Chinaman’ and ‘China Mary’.  

-- Karen Tani