Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Mikhail Reviews Allen's "Radical Duke"

My Georgetown Law colleague John Mikhail has published a review in American Heritage of Danielle Allen's Radical Duke: How One Aristocrat—and the American Revolution—Transformed Britain.  The book, Professor Mikhail writes:

tells the story of a remarkable outlier. Charles Lennox, the third Duke of Richmond, third Duke of Lennox, and Duke of Aubigny in the French nobility (1735–1806), emerges from her dramatic narrative as one of the most important and underappreciated persons in late 18th-century Britain. “Richmond was a defining figure of the revolutionary age,” Allen writes, as influential, in certain respects, as Thomas Paine, Edmund Burke, and King George III himself.
Among the startling claims that propel Radical Duke is that Richmond was the mastermind behind the Junius letters (1769-1772), a famous series of anonymous attacks on the British government, for which he recruited a dream team of gifted writers, including Paine, Burke, James Burgh, Philip Francis, and John Wilkes. Allen also maintains that Richmond collaborated with Paine and Benjamin Franklin on The Juryman’s Touchstone (1771), an obscure 95-page pamphlet that blasted Lord Mansfield for his handling of the seditious libel trial of Henry Woodfall, the publisher of the Junius letters.

If these claims are true, they place Richmond at the center of a group of radical thinkers and writers who shaped revolutions on both sides of the Atlantic.

Professor Mikhail calls Radical Duke is “captivating,” but he believes that it “appears to rest on a number of questionable assumptions.” One is that a copy of the Declaration of Independence that ended up in Sussex was Tom Paine’s gift to Richmond.  Another is that Professor Allen could safely rely upon factual statements emailed to her by an editor of Paine's papers who was not professionally trained as a historian and who apparently has not submitted his findings to peer review.  A third was that the “automated computer authorship attribution methodology" that that editor employed is in fact dependable.

"Allen may turn out to be correct about her daring new theories in Radical Duke," Professor Mikhail concludes, but "significantly more evidence and explanation are needed to turn [her] speculations into persuasive historical arguments."

--Dan Ernst