Wednesday, June 15, 2022

Zelenak and Mehrotra on Surrey

Lawrence Zelenak, Duke University School of Law, and Ajay K. Mehrotra American Bar Foundation and Northwestern Pritzker School of Law, have posted Stanley S. Surrey: A Life in Taxes, the introductory chapter to A Half-Century with the Internal Revenue Code: The Memoirs of Stanley S. Surrey (eds. Zelenak and Mehrotra, 2022):

Stanley S. Surrey was the most prominent mid-twentieth-century American tax law academic, and the federal government official with the greatest influence on tax policy over that same period (aside from politicians). His professional life with the federal tax system spanned half a century, ending only with his death at the age of 73 in 1984. As Surrey writes in his memoirs, he had good reason to "doubt that any person alive today has had as close and as varied a relationship with the Internal Revenue Code as I have had."

He divided the five decades of his professional life between academia (three early years at the University of California, Berkeley, followed by many years at Harvard Law School), and two lengthy tours of duty in the service of the U.S. Treasury Department. In his second Treasury stint he served as the Assistant Secretary of the Treasury for Tax Policy, the highest executive branch position exclusively focused on taxation. Surrey's influence on the federal tax system was deep and pervasive and continues to this day; perhaps his most enduring accomplishment has been his development of tax expenditure analysis, which since the 1970s has played a central role in a wide range of tax policy discussions.

At his death in 1984, Surrey had written polished drafts of the majority of his planned professional memoirs. Until now, the memoirs have remained unpublished in the archives of the Harvard Law School Library. Lawrence Zelenak and Ajay K. Mehrotra have edited and annotated the memoirs for publication to produce this collection. This SSRN paper contains the comprehensive introductory essay from the volume. The book, as a whole, focuses on Surrey's professional life and his contributions to tax policy, as well as extensive annotations providing important background on the people and events Surrey discusses in the memoirs.
--Dan Ernst

Tuesday, June 14, 2022

The Docket's Special Issue on Hobbs

The Docket, which is the digital sidekick to Law and History Review, has just posted a special issue prompted by the leaked draft opinion in Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization.  As the editor, Gautham Rao, writes: 

An undercurrent in the tidal wave of commentary on the Dobbs draft has concerned Justice Alito’s historical analysis that serves as the foundation of his decision to overturn Roe v. Wade. Constitutional law scholars such as Aziz Huq have explained: “For instance, the draft majority opinion spills a good deal of ink on the history of abortion regulation in England and the United States (skimming over, as it does it, the considerable periods in which abortion was left to the free choice of women).”

Here are the contents:

Editor’s Note: The Dobbs Special Issue

Dr. Lauren MacIvor Thompson: Roe v Wade and Feminism: The Limits of Public Memory

“Abortion Was a Crime”? Three Medievalists respond to “English cases dating all the way back to the 13th century corroborate the treatises’ statements that abortion was a crime.”

Felicity Turner: A View of Dobbs from the 19th Century

Alison Lefkovitz
: The Population Politics of Dobbs?

Dr. Deborah Dinner: Originalism and the Misogynist Distortion of History in Dobbs?

--Dan Ernst

CfC: Journal for Digital Legal History

 [We have the following Call for Contributions.  DRE]

The Journal for Digital Legal History (DLH) is a diamond Open Access and peer-reviewed international journal hosted by the Open UGent platform. We are pleased to invite contributions from researchers working on legal history with digital, empirical and computational approaches for our first annual issue to be published in November 2022. The journal welcomes all research questions and outputs at the intersection of legal history, digital humanities and empirical legal studies, broadly defined.

In the field of legal history, digital methods are hardly ever the centrepiece of a publication itself, if not downplayed. In 1997, Richard Evans claimed that: 'How we know about the past, what historical causation is, how we define a historical fact, whether there is such a thing as historical truth or objectivity - these are questions that most historians have happily left to one side as unnecessary distractions from their essential work in the archives' (R. Evans, In Defence of History, 1997, p. 9). Nevertheless, in the 21st century, the work of a historian or legal scholar does not stop in the archives. Often, digital or computational techniques are applied in seemingly pedestrian ways such as "searching" full texts, or they are applied in more elaborate methods to transform the historical facts embedded in our precious archival material or legal documents, to answer novel research questions or to explore well-trodden paths from an innovative perspective.

The application of digital techniques to legal history research is often overlooked or omitted from discussions on methodology. We encourage you to highlight the technical tools or methods that proved effective to your research projects, without neglecting all the trials and errors that helped structure your final choice of any particular technique. You are welcome to illustrate your work with all forms of outputs, from notebooks to graphs, networks, maps, diagrams, etc.. If you have developed software, a database or a dataset that others could reuse, feel welcome to publish it with us.

General Call for Contributions: continuous call for submissions

Submissions that address legal sources from any historical period and any part of the world are welcome. We actively encourage collaborative and multi-authored pieces by authors from different countries working across disciplines.

We accept publications in English; we can also support German, French, Spanish, Italian and Portuguese but do contact the editorial board in advance. If you wish to publish in another language than mentioned here, please consult us beforehand.

Beyond the following suggestions, feel free to contact us through the DLH website if you have any original ideas that you want to discuss.

Topic suggestions

  • Original research articles (up to 10,000 words).
  • Reproduction-pieces: Can the results of classic studies be replicated through DLH-techniques?
  • A dedicated section for your Digital Legal History events: If you are organising a panel, conference or webinar series that prominently features Digital Humanities performed on legal sources, contact us for a dedicated focus section allowing you to publish the papers or conclusions of your meeting.
  • Shorter focus pieces or provocations (around 5,000 words with fewer footnotes).
    • Conference and seminar reports.
    • Spotlight articles: inspiration from other social sciences fields on the promising benefits of specific Digital Humanities techniques that could be successfully applied to Digital Legal History.
  • Presentations or Reviews of softwares, databases, datasets, websites, and platforms.
    • Tutorials: general presentation, application through a specific study angle (legal linguistics, marginalia analysis).
  • Trials & errors: reflections on the productive role of wandering and errors in abandoned, rejected or substantially modified past projects that could help improve the current methodology (inspired by the Journal of Trial & Error).

Formats.  We are open to submissions in traditional and non-traditional formats: from traditional articles to blog posts, from plain text to linked data or hyperlinked texts, from posters to Notebooks, etc.. Illustrations could be included in the form of notebooks, graphs, diagrams, maps, networks, and images.

Timeline
.  Upon receiving your contribution, we aim to publish it within 2-4 months, depending on a positive peer-review. Please send us a short abstract of 150 words, including a provisional title, suggested format and up to five keywords. You can find the detailed guidelines for authors on the journal's website. Please include a short biographical statement for the proposed contributor(s), including the area of expertise, interests, affiliation (if applicable), and any other relevant information. We will respond to all abstract submissions within 14 days (in July and August, this may take a bit longer).

We have two specific calls for contributions open (see below):

Call for Contributions: Dedicated "Focus-section: Early Career Digital Legal Historians: dare, test and surprise".

We are pleased to invite proposals from researchers and others working with digital legal history in the early stages of their careers, for a special section of the Journal for Digital Legal History for publication in November 2022. The theme of this section is "dare, test and surprise".

Digital techniques are often not explicitly discussed, and we would encourage you to show us which techniques worked for your research - but we are also open to explaining which techniques failed. You are welcome to illustrate your work with e.g. notebooks. If you have developed software, databases or -sets that others could reuse: feel welcome to publish with us.

  • Length: Pieces in this section should count 2,500-5,000 words (up to 10,000 words max.). Do also consider alternative formats, such as fully explained Notebooks, posters with an additional explanation or linked videos, tutorials or course outlines.
  • We accept publications in English; we can also support German, French, Spanish, Italian and Portuguese but do contact the editorial board in advance. If you wish to publish in another language than mentioned here, please consult us beforehand.
  • Timeline:
    • Please send an email before July 1st, 2022, with a short proposal (150 words), including a provisional title and suggested format (and length) for your contribution. Please also include a short biographical statement for the proposed contributor(s), including the area of expertise, interests, affiliation (if applicable), and any other relevant information. We will respond to all submissions within 14 days. Mention in the subject line of the contact form to which CfC you are submitting.
    • Submission of your full contribution (of any kind) before September 30th, 2022.
    • Peer-review reports before November 4th, 2022.
    • Submission of the final version between November 18th - 25th, 2022.
    • Appearance on the website – pending positive peer review – two to three weeks after final submission.

Call for Contributions: dedicated "Focus-section: Global DLH: show, tell and teach".

We are pleased to invite proposals from researchers and others working with digital legal history at any stage of their career for a special section of the Journal for Digital Legal History for publication in November 2022. The theme of this section is "Global DLH: Show, tell and teach".

We actively encourage ECR and researchers from more diverse background to publish with us (non-English primary sources, institutions based outside Europe and North America) to contribute to this focus-section on the particular challenges they encountered in their research, either through necessary adaptations of certain digital techniques or through decisions to implement specific settings in their collaborative work.

  • Length: Pieces in this section can count 2,500-5,000 words (up to 10,000 words max.). Consider alternative formats, such as fully explained notebooks, posters with additional explanations or linked videos, tutorials or course outlines.
  • We accept publications in English; we can also support German, French, Spanish, Italian and Portuguese but do contact the editorial board in advance. If you wish to publish in another language than mentioned here, please consult us beforehand.
  • Timeline:
    • Please send an email before July 1st, 2022, with a short proposal (150 words), including a provisional title and suggested format (and length) for your contribution. Please also include a short biographical statement for the proposed contributor(s), including an area of expertise, interests, affiliation (if applicable), and any other relevant information. We will respond to all submissions within 14 days. Mention in the subject line of the contact form to which CfC you are submitting.
    • Submission of your full contribution (of any kind) before September 30th, 2022.
    • Peer-review reports before November 4th, 2022.
    • Submission of the final version between November 18th - 25th, 2022.
    • Appearance on the website – pending positive peer review – two to three weeks after final submission.

Monday, June 13, 2022

Atkinson, "Frankenstein’s Baby: The Forgotten History of Corporations, Race, and Equal Protection"

The Virginia Law Review has published "Frankenstein’s Baby: The Forgotten History of Corporations, Race, and Equal Protection," by Evelyn Atkinson (University of Chicago). The abstract:

This Article highlights the crucial role corporations played in crafting an expansive interpretation of the Fourteenth Amendment. Exposing the role of race in the history of the constitutional law of corporate personhood for the first time, this Article argues that corporations were instrumental in laying the foundation of the Equal Protection Clause that underlies civil rights jurisprudence today. By simultaneously bringing cases involving both corporations and Chinese immigrants, corporate lawyers and sympathetic federal judges crafted a broad interpretation of equal protection in order to draw a through-line from African Americans, to Chinese immigrants, and finally to corporate shareholders. At the same time that corporate litigation expanded the umbrella of protected “persons,” however, it limited the capacity of the Fourteenth Amendment to address issues of substantive inequality.

This Article reveals that central to the argument in favor of corporate constitutional personhood was a direct analogy between corporate shareholders and racial minorities. This Article thus highlights the intersection of corporate personhood and race, a connection that has rarely, if ever, been explored. Corporate lawyers’ expansive interpretation of equal protection ultimately triumphed in the Supreme Court with the twin cases of Yick Wo v. Hopkins, a bedrock of modern civil rights doctrine, and Santa Clara v. Southern Pacific Railroad, a case credited with extending equal protection rights to corporations. This is the first Article to juxtapose these two seminal cases and to expose the deep and long-standing connections between them. In so doing, this Article uncovers a neglected history of the link between corporations and race, as well as a lost history of the Fourteenth Amendment.

The full article is available here.

-- Karen Tani

Rawlings on a Thieftaker and Gaoler

Philip Rawlings, Queen Mary University of London, School of Law, has posted The Highwayman's Case: John Everett - Soldier, Robber, Publican, Gaoler:

Of the two parties named in The Highwayman's Case, only John Everett (or Everet) has left a significant trace. Born in Hitchin in 1690, he abandoned his wife and an apprenticeship in around 1709, becoming a soldier, then a court bailiff, a robber, an informer, an alehouse keeper, an inmate of the Fleet prison, a gaoler, a thieftaker, and, finally, around the age of 40, he returned to robbery, was arrested, convicted, and executed. His life provides insights into the relationship between criminals and the justice system. In the 1720s, when Everett was active, the authorities became increasingly concerned about gangs of robbers believed to be infesting London, and breaking these gangs meant depending on robbers like Everett giving evidence against their former comrades. But it was his work as a keeper in the Fleet prison that made him notorious. He was brought before the first parliamentary inquiry into the prisons, and, although never prosecuted, his involvement in the abuse of prisoners brought the financial ruin that, according to Everett, led him to commit his final robbery.

--Dan Ernst

Saturday, June 11, 2022

Weekend Roundup

  • "The Unknown History of Reproductive Rights and Eugenics: From Skinner to Roe," a webinar co-sponsored by the Georgetown University Law Center and the Robert H. Jackson Society is now viewable on C-SPAN.  The participants were Victoria F. Nourse, Michele Bratcher Goodwin, Melissa Murray, Brad Snyder, and John Q. Barrett.
  • Geoffrey R. Kirsch, a doctoral candidate in Harvard's English Department, reviews The Crooked Path to Abolition: Abraham Lincoln and the Antislavery Constitution, by James Oakes, and The Broken Constitution: Abraham Lincoln, Slavery, and the Refounding of America, by Noah Feldman (New Rambler).
  • ICYMI: Newly discovered lawsuit involving Joseph Smith in St. Louis gives new insight into Church history (Church News).  Clyde W. Ford on Key v. Mottrom, a freedom suit in seventeenth-century Virginia (HNN).  Jack Goldsmith on Watergate (Harvard Law Today). The New York Review of Books recently published an exchange between Noah Feldman and James Oakes on whether Lincoln's Emancipation Proclamation was constitutional. Over at Balkinization, John Fabian Witt weighs in.
Weekend Roundup is a weekly feature compiled by all the Legal History bloggers.


 

Friday, June 10, 2022

CFP: "Legacies of Slavery | Landscapes of Segregation"

We have the following Call for Papers/Panels:

Legacies of Slavery | Landscapes of Segregation
Universities Studying Slavery Fall 2022 Conference
September 28-October 1, 2022
Charlottesville, Virginia

In Fall 2022, the University of Virginia and its President’s Commission on the University in the Age of Segregation (PCUAS) will host the USS conference: Legacies of Slavery | Landscapes of Segregation, highlighting slavery’s many enduring legacies after emancipation and also confront the American academy’s history of both benefiting from and perpetuating those legacies. We seek to examine a wide variety of topics: reconstruction, disfranchisement, redlining, racially restrictive zoning, racial terrorism, policing and incarceration, racist science’s impacts on public policy, and resulting inequalities in health, industry, housing, and education. Although the central theme focuses on the post-emancipation world, the conference will address a wide array of topics related to slavery, slavery’s afterlives, and universities.

We encourage submissions for both single papers and full panel proposals (max. 4 presenters and moderator/chair) that address any aspects of the theme as well as those that consider the history, public history, preservation, or memorialization of sites of enslavement or segregation. Faculty, graduate students, public historians, preservationists, university administrators, and independent scholars are welcome to submit individual papers or full panels. We also invite undergraduate student posters on research, activism, and student organizational work, among other topics.

Panel proposal submissions must include a 125-word maximum panel description that includes a proposed title as well as individual 250-word maximum paper proposals and brief bios (100 words max) for each participant.

Individual paper and poster proposal submissions should provide 250-word proposal and 100-word maximum brief bio.

Proposals are due by July 1, 2022

Please submit proposals at USS Conference Fall 2022.

-- Karen Tani

Mazzone on Incorporating the Guarantee Clause

Jason Mazzone, University of Illinois College of Law, has posted The Incorporation of the Republican Guarantee Clause, which is forthcoming in the Notre Dame Law Review:

This Article makes the case for understanding the Fourteenth Amendment to incorporate the Republican Guarantee Clause of Article IV. Incorporation shifts the focus of the Guarantee Clause from the interests of states to the interests of citizens; from protecting popular sovereignty as a political ideal to safeguarding more specifically rights that citizens hold and exercise in a republican system. Once incorporated, the Guarantee Clause should be understood to require states themselves to maintain a republican form of government and to act to correct departures from republicanism within their own governing arrangements. In addition, an incorporated Guarantee Clause informs the meaning of rights protected against state interference under Section 1 of the Fourteenth Amendment: safeguards for privileges and immunities, due process of law, and equal protection of the laws, are all usefully understood with an eye to republicanism. So, too, an incorporated Guarantee Clause informs the meaning of provisions of the Bill of Rights when they are applied to state governments. Incorporation also has implications for the national government: its role shifts from a duty owed to the states to an obligation to protect from state interference citizenship rights that serve republican ends. Finally, incorporation alters the traditional assessment that Guarantee Clause claims are nonjusticiable.
--Dan Ernst

Thursday, June 9, 2022

CFP: "Somerset v. Steuart @ 250"

We have the following Call for Papers:
Somerset v. Steuart @ 250: Facts, Interpretations, and Legacies

In recent years, the Somerset v. Steuart trial of 1772 has emerged as an event of much discussion in the history of transatlantic antislavery. Scholars have debated the decision’s importance and centrality to the emancipatory impulses in the British Atlantic, and, more recently, its role in the outbreak of the American Revolution. Some have argued that Lord Mansfield’s decision in James Somerset’s favor was a central, even epochal event, while others maintain that North Americans scarcely noticed the decision. With the two hundred and fiftieth anniversary of the trial upon us, the David Center is convening a scholarly symposium to continue this conversation and offer fresh appraisals of the causes, nature, and consequences of the decision.

The program committee seeks paper proposals from scholars in all fields to assess what we have learned and how we might interpret events before, during, and after the 1772 decision. We seek to evaluate the origins of the trial and to examine the question of how important the trial was to the momentous changes of the period,

Potential topics and themes include but are not limited to:

· New analysis on the causes and nature of the Somerset decision in 1772.

· Exploration of the impact and reception of the Somerset decision.

· The direct and indirect effects of the decision on the lives of the enslaved and enslavers.

· The influence of the decision on the law, the empire, the politics, and the African diaspora within the British Empire and beyond it.

· The importance or unimportance of ideas, of law, and of courts.

· The historiography of the Somerset case.

· Memory and public commemoration of the decision, both historically and contemporaneously.

· The current use and depiction of the case in educational materials, public debates, the media, and sites of public history.

· The role of James Somerset himself and other African actors.

We will meet on Thursday and Friday, December 1-2, 2022, for online and in-person sessions, all of which will be open to the public. Papers will be distributed in advance. Participants should be committed to read all the papers and to serve as a discussion leader for another session. We expect to produce a book of revised essays from the conference to be published in a new book series of the David Center for the American Revolution with University of Pennsylvania Press.

To propose a paper, please send an abstract of 250 words, a one-page cv, and a brief cover letter about how this topic fits into your past, present, and/or developing research, by June 15, 2022, to Interfolio.

-- Karen Tani

Legal & Literary Perspectives on Fox-hunting

Ross Davies's edited work, Regulation & Imagination: Legal & Literary Perspectives on Fox-hunting, is now out from Green Bag Press:

This is our first try at an odd mode of legal scholarship: the coffee-table treatise. It is
handsome enough to merit display (many nice pictures, and maps), and scholarly enough to merit study (many eloquent experts).

The story at the center of the book — Arthur Conan Doyle's The King of the Foxes — is both an exciting tale and a provocative prompt for discussion of law and literature affecting, and affected by, fox-hunting.
Jennifer L. Behrens, Duke University School of Law, J. Michael Goodson Law Library, has separately posted her chapter from the volume, On the Scent: A History of 'The King of the Foxes' Autograph Manuscript:
Frank Hogan (LC)
The autograph manuscript of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's 1898 short story "The King of the Foxes" now resides in the Dartmouth College Library. While the complete provenance of the manuscript remains elusive, bookplates and notations provide enough information to sketch an approximate timeline of its travels and a brief biography of several holders, including legendary attorney and former American Bar Association president Frank Hogan (1877-1944), the founder of law firm Hogan & Hartson (now Hogan Lovells). 

--Dan Ernst

Wednesday, June 8, 2022

JPH 34:3

Journal of Policy History 34:3 (July 2022) has been published online:

Explaining the Prevalence of State Constitutional Conventions in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries
John Dinan

Defining Rockefeller Republicanism: Promise and Peril at the Edge of the Liberal Consensus, 1958–1975
Marsha E. Barrett

From Labor Rights to the Right to Work: Constituting and Resisting Social Citizenship, 1932–1953
Dolores Janiewski

An Industry Worth Protecting? The Manufacturers Aircraft Association’s Struggle against the British Surplus, 1919–1922
Sean Seyer

Evolution and Electoral Implications of Congressional Gun Control Issue Framing: “From Crime Control to Mass Shootings”
Genevieve Quinn

--Dan Ernst

Tate's "Power and Justice in Medieval England"

Joshua C. Tate,  SMU Dedman School of Law, has published Power and Justice in Medieval England: The Law of Patronage and the Royal Courts (Yale University Press) in the Yale Law Library Series in Legal History and Reference:

Appointing a parson to the local church following a vacancy—an “advowson”—was one of the most important rights in medieval England. The king, the monasteries, and local landowners all wanted to control advowsons because they meant political, social, and economic influence. The question of law turned on who had the superior legal claim to the vacancy—which was a type of property—at the time the position needed to be filled.

In tracing how these conflicts were resolved, Joshua C. Tate takes a sharply different view from that of historians who focus only on questions of land ownership, and he shows that the English needed new legal contours to address the questions of ownership and possession that arose from these disputes. Tate argues that the innovations made necessary by advowson law helped give birth to modern common law and common law courts.

Here are some endorsements:

“A praiseworthy and original investigation of a subject that straddled the line between secular and spiritual: the early history of the English common law of advowsons.”—R.H. Helmholz, University of Chicago Law School
 
"Tate brings to this book just the qualities it needs: he asks the right questions and knows the common law and canon law materials which supply the answers. His study makes a significant contribution to our understanding of an important part of the early English Common Law."—Paul Brand, University of Oxford

“It has been a great pleasure to watch what began as a tentative, but intriguing, doctoral dissertation turn through a series of articles on seemingly small points into the small masterpiece that is this book.”—Charles Donahue Jr., Harvard Law School
–Dan Ernst

Tuesday, June 7, 2022

Legal History at the American Political History Conference, June 9-11, 2022

The program for this week's American Political History Conference includes many items of note for readers of this blog. Here's a sampling: 

DOCUMENTING CRIMINALIZATION, CONFINEMENT, AND RESISTANCE THROUGH HISTORY LAB RESEARCH COLLABORATIONS

  • Matt Lassiter, University of Michigan, Director of Policing and Social Justice History Lab and lead author of the website exhibit "Detroit Under Fire: Police Violence, Crime Politics, and the Struggle for Racial Justice in the Civil Rights Era"
  • Nicole Navarro, University of Michigan, Graduate Supervisor of Policing and Social Justice History Lab and coauthor/mapping consultant of "Detroit Under Fire"
  • Alexander Stephens, University of Michigan, Coordinator of U-M Carceral State Project’s “Immigration and the Carceral State” research initiative and community liaison to the Michigan Immigrant Rights Center’s “Know Your Rights” project
  • Alex Burnett, University of Michigan, Graduate Coordinator of Prisoner Uprisings in America Lab and coauthor of “Kinross Uprising, Michigan 2016: The Silenced Revolt Over Basic Human Rights in Prison”
 
DE JURE POLITICS: HOW LAW SHAPED MODERN POLITICS AND SOCIETY

Moderator: Natalia Mehlman-Petrzela, The New School

Panelists: 

  • Logan Sawyer, University of Georgia School of Law, “Government by Originalism: Constitutional Law and Party Politics Inside the Reagan Department of Justice, 1983-1988” 
  • Devan Lindey, Purdue University, “Experience as Education: The Political Effects of Student Life and Judeo-Christian Education at Grove City College”
  • Anne Blaschke, University of Massachusetts—Boston, “Title IX at 50"


PROGRESSIVE ERA POLITICS

Moderator: Bruce Schulman, Boston University

Panelists: 

  • Kimberly Hamlin, Miami University in Ohio, “How Raising the Age of Sexual Consent in the 1890s Convinced Female Reforms that They Needed the Vote”
  • Leslie Lindenauer and H. Howell Williams, Western Connecticut State University, “Workers Built Danbury: Deindustrialized Memory in a Hatting Town”
  • Josh Kluever, Binghamton University (SUNY), “Sorry Waldman, We Just Couldn’t Help It: Socialist State Legislators in New York, 1912-1922”


CARCERAL STATE, CARCERAL SOCIETY

Moderator: Elizabeth Hinton, Yale University

Panelists: 

  • Max Felker-Kantor, Ball State University, “Arresting the Demand for Drugs: DARE and the Politics of Supply and Demand Reduction in the War on Drugs”
  • Charlotte Rosen, Northwestern University, “The Wheels of Justice Are Grinding to a Halt: Harris v. Philadelphia and the Dilemma of Mass Imprisonment in the 1990s Law and Order Philadelphia”
  • Kenneth S. Alyass, Harvard University, “The People’s War on Drugs: Community Activism, the Carceral State, and the Crack Crisis in 1980s Detroit”
  • Michael Z. Dean, UCLA, “The Politics of Decarceration in Ronald Reagan’s California”


ENVISIONING A COMPASSIONATE STATE: LEFT AND LIBERAL CHALLENGES TO
“TOUGH” POLICIES IN THE TWENTIETH-CENTURY UNITED STATES ** 

Moderator: LaDale Winling, Virginia Tech

Panelists: 

  • Brooke Depenbusch, Colgate University, “The Lost Promise of General Relief: Activists, Reformers, and the Midcentury Struggle to Expand the Safety Net”
  • Emma Amador, University of Connecticut, Storrs, “Demanding Equal Care: Puerto Rican Women Activists, US Colonialism, and the Politics of Social Security in Puerto Rico”
  • Amanda Hughett, University of Illinois Springfield, “‘An Honest Day’s Pay for an Honest Day’s Work’: Liberal Lawyers, Incarcerated Activists, and the Remaking of Prison Labor During the 1970s”


RACIAL INNOCENCE AND CARCERAL POWER IN THE TWENTIETH-CENTURY
UNITED STATES 

Moderator: Matthew Lassiter, University of Michigan 

Panelists: 

  • Kathleen Frydl, “Corporate Personhood, the ‘Guilty Mind,’ and the 1980s War on Drugs”
  • Paul M. Renfro, Florida State University, “Criminalizing CARE: AIDS, the Ryan White CARE Act, and the Politics of Innocence”
  • Kirstine Taylor, Ohio University, “Producing Racial Innocence: The Fall of Chain Gangs and the Rise of Prisons in North Carolina"
  • Abby Whitaker, Temple University, “‘C is for Colorblindness’: Sesame Street, Race, and the Transformation of Liberalism"


REPRODUCTIVE RIGHTS AND POLITICS  

Moderator: Gillian Frank, Host of Sexing History Podcast 

Panelists: 

  • Jennifer Holland, University of Oklahoma
  • Amrita Chakrabarti Myers, Indiana University
  • Mary Ziegler, Florida State University


ROUNDTABLE: CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY IS POLITICAL HISTORY

Moderator: Yvonne Pitts, Purdue University 

Panelists: 

  • H. Robert Baker, Georgia State University
  • Jane Manners, Temple University
  • Julian Mortenson, University of Michigan
  • Joshua Sellers, Arizona State Law School


DEBATES OVER THE REGULATORY STATE

Moderator: Daniel Rowe, Oxford University

Panelists: 

  • Patrick Andelic, Northumbria University, “Smoke-Free Rooms: The Waxman Committee and the Congressional Campaign against Big Tobacco”
  • Jeff Berryhill, Rutgers University, “Condoms, Clean Needles, and Crisis: Conflict over HIV/AIDS Prevention in New York City, 1988-1994”
  • Whitney McIntosh, Columbia University, “Reclaiming the Mainstream: The Individualist Feminist Push to Protect Freedom of Choice, 1980-1995”


AUTHOR MEETS CRITICS: DISCUSSION OF WILLIAM NOVAK’S NEW DEMOCRACY: THE CREATION OF THE MODERN AMERICAN STATE

  • William Novak, University of Michigan
  • Sophia Lee, University of Pennsylvania
  • Ajay Mehrotra, ABF/Northwestern University
  • James Sparrow, University of Chicago
  • Karen Tani, University of Pennsylvania


And there is more! The full program is available here. Some panels are accessible virtually.

-- Karen Tani

2022-23 Katz Center fellows: "Jews and Modern Legal Culture"

"Jews and Modern Legal Culture" is the theme of the Herbert D. Katz Center for Advanced Judaic Studies at the University of Pennsylvania in 2022-23. Here's an announcement about the Katz Center's incoming fellowship class:

The Katz Center is thrilled to announce the cohort for the 2022–23 academic year, engaging the theme of Jews and Modern Legal Culture. The fellows will join us from Israel, France, Germany, Canada, and the United States, and represent a range of methodological, disciplinary, and historical specializations. Our goal as always is to promote generative intellectual exchange not only among the fellows but also with the Penn community and the public more broadly.

Continuing and building on the 2021–22 fellowship year devoted to Rethinking Premodern Jewish Legal Cultures, the Katz Center’s coming year turns its attention to the study of law between the eighteenth and twenty-first centuries, an era of transition from a world of empires to the modern age of the nation-state and international law. 

We are also pleased to include in this announcement the names of two University of Pennsylvania faculty members who will join the cohort as part of a new Penn faculty fellowship initiative. We are grateful to the deans of the School of Arts and Sciences and Graduate School of Education for their support. 

We look forward to hosting these distinguished scholars and seeing how they expand our understanding of Jewish culture’s engagement with law, democracy, the state, modernity, and justice.

2022–2023 Katz Center Fellows

Itamar Ben Ami, Humboldt University of Berlin
Ruth Meltzer Fellowship
Legal Theocracy: The Ultra-Orthodox Adaptation of Halakhah to the Statist Era

Sigal Ben-Porath, Graduate School of Education
University of Pennsylvania Faculty Fellowship
Free Speech for and about Jews: A Legal and Normative Analysis

Leora Bilsky, Tel Aviv University
Primo Levi Fellowship
Cultural Genocide in the Eichmann Trial: A View from Below

Emmanuel Bloch, UC Berkeley School of Law
Thomas and Elissa Ellant Katz Fellowship
The Tsni’ut Laws: Halakhah and Metahalakhah in the Twentieth and Twenty-First Centuries

Yonatan Y. Brafman, Tufts University
Thomas and Elissa Ellant Katz Fellowship
Jewish Law, Philosophy, Systematicity

Julie Cooper, Tel Aviv University
Ariel and Joshua Weiner Family Fellowship
Legal Foundations of the Diasporic Jewish Nation

Carolyn J. Dean, Yale University
Primo Levi Fellowship
Bystanders, Jews, and the Legal Imagination in Vichy France

Noëmie Duhaut, Leibniz Institute of European History, Mainz
Ariel and Joshua Weiner Family Fellowship
French Jews, Legal Practice, and the Construction of Empire

Ayala Fader, Fordham University
Ivan and Nina Ross Family Fellowship
Haredi Jews, Health, and Legal Cultures

Marc Flandreau, Department of History
University of Pennsylvania Faculty Fellowship
Sovereign Default, International Law, and the Anglo-Jewish Financial Community in the Nineteenth Century

Elisabeth Gallas, Leibniz Institute for Jewish History and Culture – Simon Dubnow
Jody Ellant and Howard Reiter Family Fellowship
“We Accuse!”: History of Jewish Indictments in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries

Nan Goodman, University of Colorado
Ivan and Nina Ross Family Fellowship
The Memory of Sabbatianism and American Legal Culture

Tafat Hacohen-Bick, Ben Gurion University of the Negev
Louis Apfelbaum and Hortense Braunstein Apfelbaum Fellowship
Yirah, Law, and the Birth of Modern Hebrew Literature

Dana Hollander, McMaster University
Louis Apfelbaum and Hortense Braunstein Apfelbaum Fellowship
German Legal Comparatism and the Modern Understanding of Jewish Law

Tamir Karkason, Martin Luther University of Halle – Wittenberg
Dalck and Rose Feith Family Fellowship
Translating Citizenship: Jews and Ottoman Law in the Nineteenth Century

Jessica Marglin, University of Southern California
Thomas and Elissa Ellant Katz Fellowship
The Extraterritorial Mediterranean: Jews, Sovereignty, and Law in the Nineteenth Century

Thomas Prendergast, Hebrew University of Jerusalem
Maurice Amado Foundation Fellowship
Habsburg Jewish Legal Scholars, Sociology, and the Global Imperial Turn

Chaim Saiman, Villanova University
Albert J. Wood Fellowship
The New American Halakhah: Praxis of Contemporary American Beth Dins

Nomi Stolzenberg, University of Southern California
Ellie and Herbert D. Katz Distinguished Fellowship
The Place of the Jew in the Law of Religious Liberty

Elly Teman, Ruppin Academic Center, Israel
Charles W. and Sally Rothfeld Fellowship
Surrogacy in Israel: Between Jewish and Secular Law

Avishalom Westreich, College of Law and Business, Israel
Israel Institute Visiting Faculty Fellowship; Roberta and Stanley Bogen Visiting Scholar
The Civil Revolution of Jewish Law in Israel

Sarah Zager, St. Olaf College
Ruth Meltzer Fellowship
Deontology and Virtue Ethics in Halakhah

-- Karen Tani

Monday, June 6, 2022

The Enduring Legacy of John Jay

The Historical Society of the New York Courts has announced The Enduring Legacy of John Jay: A Virtual Seminar, to be conducted on June 9, 2022 from 6:00 PM to 8:00 PM EDT.  Register here.

John Jay (NYPL)
While many may be familiar with Founding Fathers such as Franklin, Hamilton, and Washington, they may not be as aware of the impact of America’s first Chief Justice of both the NY Courts and the U.S. Supreme Court, John Jay. His influence on America’s jurisprudence is profound.

Following in the first Chief Justice’s footsteps, present-day Chief Judge Janet DiFiore will give remarks remembering John Jay as Founding Father of NY and the nation’s courts in this auspicious year of the NY Court of Appeals’ 175th anniversary.

This conversation will be moderated by Hon. Albert M. Rosenblatt, retired NY Court of Appeals Associate Judge, with Hon. Mark C. Dillon, Appellate Division, Second Department Associate Justice, and Walter Stahr, Counsel for EMP Global, both John Jay biographers, and dives into Jay’s jurisprudence in his critical role as founder of the nation’s legal system. The program will also explore Jay as diplomat, Governor, abolitionist and family man.

--Dan Ernst

Saturday, June 4, 2022

Weekend Roundup

  • James Oakes's review in the New York Review of Books of Noah Feldman's The Broken Constitution has brought a reply from Feldman, a response from Oakes--both here--and a comment from John Fabian Witt (Balkinization).
  • ICYMI, Justice Alito Edition:  Leslie J. Reagan on What Alito Gets Wrong About the History of Abortion in America (Politico).  Anthony Tang on What Justice Alito Can Learn From a 114-Year-Old Sex Abuse Scandal (Slate).  Same-sex marriages should be considered "newer than cell phones," JSTOR observes in this pointer to "What, Another Female Husband?": The Prehistory of Same-Sex Marriage in America, by Rachel Hope Cleves, in the Journal of American History 101 (March 2015): 1055-1081.
  • ICYMI: Tim Naftali on The Death of Nonpartisan Presidential History (The Atlantic). Suzanne McGee on 5 Historic Supreme Court Rulings Based on the 14th Amendment (History Channel).  Claire Potter on what Emma Goldman's 1919 deportation hearing teaches about censorship embedded in other laws (Political Junkie). Garrett Epps on The Supreme Court and the Originalist Fallacy (Washington Monthly).
  • Update: Supreme Court Justice Russell Brown on the legal history of Medicine Hat (Medicine Hat News).

Weekend Roundup is a weekly feature compiled by all the Legal History bloggers.

Friday, June 3, 2022

Rose on Property Law and Inequality

Carol M. Rose, University of Arizona James E. Rogers College of Law, has posted Property Law and Inequality: Lessons from Racially Restrictive Covenants, which is forthcoming in the Northwestern University Law Review:

A longstanding justification for the institution of property is that it encourages effort and planning, enabling not only individual wealth creation but indirectly wealth in an entire society. Equal opportunity is a precondition for this happy outcome, but some have argued that past inequalities of opportunity have distorted wealth distribution in contemporary America. This article explores the possible role of property law in such a distortion, using the historical example of racially restrictive covenants in the first half of the twentieth century. I will argue that the increasing professionalization and standardization of real estate practices in that era included racial covenants to appeal to a predominately white market clientele, resulting in a curtailment of opportunities of African Americans to acquire wealth in real estate. Racial covenants have been unenforceable under Constitutional law since 1948, but I will argue that they were also a distortion of standard property law and that they undermined the principles on which property law rests. Courts might have recognized this at the outset and later, but for some reasons that this article suggests, they did not, with long lasting repercussions for racial wealth inequalities.
--Dan Ernst

Thursday, June 2, 2022

Jeon on Women-Led, Non-Lawyer Legal Aid in Boston

Kelsea A. Jeon, the holder of an M.Phil in Socio-Legal Research from the University of Oxford, has published Legal Aid Without Lawyers: How Boston’s Nonlawyers Delivered and Shaped Justice for the Poor, 1879–1921 in the Georgetown Journal on Poverty Law & Policy:

Women nonlawyers were some of the first actors to provide organized legal aid to America’s poor. Yet, today, unauthorized practice of law statutes bar nonlawyers from providing legal help, citing concerns about malpractice and public harm. This Article uses a historical case study to challenge conceptions that nonlawyers cannot provide effective legal services to the people. The study focuses on the development of legal aid in Boston via two organizations, the nonlawyer-led Women’s Educational and Industrial Union and the lawyer-centric Boston Legal Aid Society. Although organized legal aid in Boston began with the nonlawyers at the Union, they were eventually overtaken by the lawyer-centric Legal Aid Society. This paper examines this transition in legal aid practitioners, emphasizing how nonlawyers provided effective legal help. In doing so, it challenges the modern-day conception that access to justice requires access to an attorney and serves as a powerful counter to claims that nonlawyer practitioners endanger the public.
Her undergraduate thesis at Yale was This 'Order' Must Be Annihilated: How Benjamin Austin's Call to Abolish Lawyers Shaped Early Understandings of Access to Justice, 1786-1819.

 --Dan Ernst

Wednesday, June 1, 2022

Cornell on Arms Regulation, 1328-1928

The June 2022 issue of the UC Davis Law Review includes the symposium, The 2nd Amendment at the Supreme Court: “700 Years of History” and the Modern Effects of Guns in Public.  Contributions include The Long Arc of Arms Regulation in Public: From Surety to Permitting, 1328–1928, by Saul Cornell, Fordham University:
This Article charts the six-century arc of arms regulation in public in the Anglo-American legal tradition. It summarizes existing historical scholarship, exposes historical flaws in gun rights activist writing pretending to be engaged in serious scholarly inquiry, including the dubious claims advanced in the many gun rights amicus briefs filed in Bruen, and presents new research crucial to understanding the history of gun regulation and enforcement.

--Dan Ernst

Gillespie and Breen's New Legal and Social History of New Zealand

Alexander Gillespie and Claire Breen, University of Waikato, have published People, Power, and Law: A New Zealand History with Hart Publishing:

This book offers a unique insight into the key legal and social issues at play in New Zealand today. Tackling the most pressing issues, it tracks the evolution of these societal problems from 1840 to the present day.  Issues explored include: racism; the position of women; the position of Maori, free speech, and censorship. Through these issues, the authors track New Zealand’s evolution to one of the most famously liberal and tolerant societies in the world.

For 20 percent off, use the code GLR A6AUK for UK orders and GLR A6AUS for US orders.

--Dan Ernst

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Reproductive Rights from Skinner to Roe

Register today for tomorrow’s seminar, The Unknown History of Reproductive Rights and Eugenics: From Skinner to Roe, 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM ET, which is cosponored by the Georgetown University Law Center and the Robert H. Jackson Society.  Click here to RSVP to attend in-person at Georgetown Law (Hotung 2000).  Click here to RSVP for the Zoom Webinar Link.

The Supreme Court is expected to decide a momentous reproductive rights case in June 2022 that could have enormous implications for the country and pending state legislation. Very few people remember, however, the Court's first reproductive rights case, Skinner v. Oklahoma, decided June 1, 1942. This event brings experts together to discuss the legal and historical importance of that decision for the Court's new case, including its dark history (eugenics).

The panel participants will be Victoria F. Nourse, Ralph W. Whitworth Professor of Law at Georgetown Law; Michele Bratcher Goodwin, Chancellor’s Professor of Law at the University of California-Irvine; Melissa Murray, Frederick I. and Grace Stokes Professor of Law at New York University;  Brad Snyder, Professor of Law and Anne Fleming Research Professor at Georgetown; and John Q. Barrett, St. John's University School of Law.

---Dan Ernst

Children and the Law: A Conference in Honor of Michael Grossberg

We have the following announcement, regarding a November 10, 2022, pre-conference convening at this year's meeting of the American Society for Legal History:

Children and the Law: A Conference in Honor of Michael Grossberg

Mini-Conference Schedule

9:30am “Saving Our Kids”

Opening Remarks by Laura Edwards (Princeton University) & Dirk Hartog (Princeton University)
10-11:30am “Who Gets the Child?”
Comment by Steven Mintz (University of Texas, Austin)

Chelsea Chamberlain (University of Pennsylvania), "Perpetual Children": Mental Disability, Institutional Commitment, and the Intimate State

Naama Maor (Tel Aviv University), “We Cannot be Hoodwinked into Making Paroles”: Delinquent Children, State Institutions, and the Boundaries of Juvenile Justice

Kristen McCabe Lashua (Vanguard University of Southern California), “If the boy’s word is to be taken”: Child Testimonies in Early Modern England

Nathan Stenberg (University of Minnesota), “A Peculiar Case”: Disability, Performance, and the Legal (De)Construction of Institutionalized Children's Personhood at the Pennhurst State School & Hospital
11:45-12:30 Lunch

12:45-2:15pm “A Protected Childhood”
Comment by Barbara Welke (University of Minnesota)

Wangui Muigai (Brandeis University), The Tenth Crusade: Baby-Saving, Racial Violence, and the NAACP

Yukako Otori (Tokyo University of Foreign Studies), Esther Kaplan's Saga: From an Undesirable Immigrant to an Undeportable "Child"

Ivón Padilla-Rodríguez (University of Illinois Chicago), The Double Removal of Migrant Youth: Late-Twentieth Century Data Collection and Education Law as U.S. Immigration Deterrence

Shani Roper (University of the West Indies), Sitting at Intersections: Institutionalized Children and the Law in Colonial Jamaica 1904 to 1950

Doris Morgan Rueda (University of Nevada, Las Vegas), “The Boy is Large for His Age”: Making Age in Arizona’s Early Juvenile Court, 1907-1920
2:30-4pm “Legal Rights for Children?”
Comment by David Tanenhaus (University of Nevada, Las Vegas)

Tera Agyepong (DePaul University & American Bar Foundation), Constructing Race and Gendered Delinquency in the Juvenile Justice System

Juandrea Bates (Winona State University), Bringing Child Protection Home: Juveniles as Initiators of Child Protection Suits in Buenos Aires 1890-1930

Emily Prifogle (University of Michigan), Rural Students and a “Right” to Local Schools

Kathryn Schumaker (University of Oklahoma), Desegregating Discipline: Corporal Punishment and Children's Rights in the Classroom in the 1970s
4:15pm Afterward
Introduction of Michael Grossberg by Ajay Mehrotra (American Bar Foundation and Northwestern University) & Bengt Sandin (Linköping University in Sweden)

Closing Remarks by Michael Grossberg

5pm Cocktail Reception

 

-- Karen Tani

Monday, May 30, 2022

Jouet on Camus's (and Amsterdam's) Influence on Furman

Mugambi Jouet, McGill Faculty of Law, has posted A Lost Chapter in Death Penalty History: Furman v. Georgia, Albert Camus, and the Normative Challenge to Capital Punishment, which is forthcoming in the American Journal of Criminal Law:

Overlooked historical sources call into question the standard narrative that the Supreme Court’s landmark decision in Furman v. Georgia (1972), which temporarily abolished the death penalty, reflected a challenge to its arbitrary, capricious, and discriminatory application. This Article examines materials that scholars have neglected, including the main brief in Aikens v. California, a companion case to Furman that presented the fundamental constitutional claim: the death penalty is inherently cruel and unusual.

Aikens was largely forgotten to history after it became moot, leaving Furman as the main case before the Court. The Aikens brief’s humanistic claims and rhetoric are at odds with the widespread idea that Furman was a case about administrative or procedural problems with capital punishment. This is truer of the Furman decision itself than of the way the case was litigated. Depicting any execution as “barbarity,” as an “atavistic horror,” the Aikens brief marshaled an argument that has garnered much less traction in modern America than Europe: the death penalty is an affront to human dignity. Yet the transatlantic divergence in framing abolitionism was not always as pronounced as it came to be in Furman’s aftermath. Since the Enlightenment, American and European abolitionists had long emphasized normative arguments against capital punishment, thereby revealing why they played a central role in Aikens-Furman.

Strikingly, the Aikens brief insistently quoted a European figure whose role in this seminal Supreme Court case has received no attention: Albert Camus. “Reflections on the Guillotine,” Camus’s denunciation of the death penalty’s inhumanity, is among the sources prominently featured in the Aikens-Furman briefs. The architect of this strategy was Anthony Amsterdam, a famed litigator. Subsequent generations of American abolitionists have placed less weight on humanistic objections to executions, instead stressing procedural and administrative claims. This shift has obscured how a lost chapter in death penalty history unfolded.

These events are key to understanding the evolution of capital punishment, from its resurgence in the late twentieth century to its present decline as the number of executions nears record lows. On Furman’s fiftieth anniversary, the Article offers another window into the past as scholars anticipate a future constitutional challenge to the death penalty in one or two generations. 

--Dan Ernst

Saturday, May 28, 2022

Weekend Roundup

  • "How We Told the Ongoing Story of Title IX": Laura Mogulescu, Curator of Women's History Collections for the Center for Women's History at the New-York Historical Society, writes for History News Network about the exhibition "Title IX: Activism On and Off the Field."
  • Congratulations to Lea VanderVelde upon her being named a 2022 University Distinguished Chair at the University of Iowa.  “The award is one of the highest bestowed on Iowa faculty. It recognizes tenured scholars of national and international distinction who are making a significant positive impact within the university, state of Iowa, and beyond through teaching, research, and/or scholarship.”  (Iowa Now).
  • Nominations are due June 1 for ASLH awards celebrating “legal history research published or defended in the previous calendar year.”  More.
  • "The Association of Research of the Professional History of the Members of the Austrian Bar Discredited between 1938 and 1945" announces the second edition of Advokaten 1938, which deals with "the fates of 2,200 lawyers and trainee lawyers registered with the regional bar organisations of Austria on January 1, 1938, who were either barred from continuing their training or from practicing the legal profession from 1938 to 1945."  More.
  • A report on that symposium on Lincoln the Lawyer at the Quincy History Museum (WGEM).
  • Mapping racially restrictive covenants in Rochester, Minnesota (mprnews).
  •  ICYMI: What the Suffragists Really Thought about Abortion? by Treva B. Lindsey, Ohio State University (Smithsonian).  How Fred Korematsu defied Japanese incarceration in the U.S. during WWII (NatGeo). How the long and strange history of wiretapping continues to shape how Americans conceive of surveillance and privacy (Nation).  Washington State’s anti-tipping law of 1909 (HistoryLink.org). Joseph Fishkin and William E. Forbath on making progressive politics constitutional again (Boston Review). "Joshua Montefiore, First Jewish Author to Publish a Law Book in America" (In Custodia Legis).

Weekend Roundup is a weekly feature compiled by all the Legal History bloggers.

Friday, May 27, 2022

Schmidt on the 13th Amendment's Influence on the 14th

Christopher W. Schmidt, Chicago-Kent College of Law, has posted Thirteenth Amendment Echoes in Fourteenth Amendment Doctrine, which is forthcoming in the Hastings Law Journal:

This Article argues that to better understand the historical development of Fourteenth Amendment antidiscrimination doctrine, we should look to the Thirteenth Amendment. The Fourteenth Amendment was drafted in response to debates over the meaning of the Thirteenth Amendment; it was widely understood at the time of ratification as building upon the constitutional commitments embodied in the Thirteenth Amendment; and assumptions about liberty and equality more commonly associated with the Thirteenth Amendment have had a recurring, if underappreciated, influence on judicial interpretations of the Fourteenth Amendment.

I trace these Thirteenth Amendment influences on the Fourteenth Amendment from Reconstruction to some of the Supreme Court’s most important twentieth-century racial discrimination cases—such as Buchanan v. Warley, Shelley v. Kraemer, and Brown v. Board of Education—and through more recent decisions, including Obergefell v. Hodges, that extend constitutional antidiscrimination protections beyond race. Once we recover these recurrent, consequential, but rarely acknowledged Thirteenth Amendment echoes in Fourteenth Amendment doctrine, we can recognize the existence of a constitutional principle that operates alongside the tiers-of-scrutiny approach that dominates modern Fourteenth Amendment doctrine. This principle—which I label the principle of equality of rights—modulates the strength of the nondiscrimination requirement to account for the importance of the sphere of activity at issue. Despite its simplicity and intuitive attractiveness, and its foundations in the original understanding of the Fourteenth Amendment, the equality of rights principle has proven deeply unsettling across time, feared both for its potential to radically expand the reach of constitutional antidiscrimination norms and its potential to excessively constrain these norms. I argue that if constitutional law were to recognize and accept this principle, our Fourteenth Amendment doctrine would better reflect foundational commitments of Reconstruction, better explain the Court’s most consequential interpretations of the Equal Protection Clause, and better serve the needs of a nation still struggling to realize the emancipatory vision of the Thirteenth Amendment.

--Dan Ernst

Thursday, May 26, 2022

Watergate at 50

The Watergate (LC)
[We have the following announcement.  DRE]

The Watergate Break-in: 50 Years Later

A two-day online conference (June 9-10, 2022) reflecting on the fiftieth anniversary of the Watergate break-in, convened by Dr Shane O’Sullivan (Kingston School of Art) and Dr Melissa Graves (Dept of Intelligence and Security Studies, The Citadel)

There has been a resurgence of interest in Watergate in recent years, with the revelations of the Mueller investigation and presidential impeachment hearings benchmarked against the historical nadir of political malfeasance, and each new scandal dubbed “worse than Watergate.” At the same time, new document releases have allowed scholars to probe the CIA’s internal history of Watergate and the backgrounds of the burglars and their associations with the Agency in unprecedented detail, and a new study of the FBI’s Watergate investigation has seen the Bureau’s lead investigators emerge from the shadow of Woodward and Bernstein’s reporting to reclaim key breakthroughs in the case for the Bureau’s investigation team.

Fifty years after the break-in, the surviving investigators and prosecutors still can’t understand why the burglars entered DNC headquarters in the early morning hours of June 17, 1972; or how the experienced intelligence operatives in the break-in team made such elementary mistakes, resulting in their arrests and President Nixon’s resignation two years later.

While much has been written about the White House cover-up and the Nixon White House tapes, the stories of the burglars and the FBI investigation are less well-known, and the conference organisers aim to widen the scope of Watergate scholarship and explore some of the remaining mysteries of the case. Conference speakers include historians, academics, published authors on the case and Watergate prosecutors and investigators.

Siegel, Mayeri, & Murray on "Equal Protection in Dobbs and Beyond"

This forthcoming essay by legal historians and constitutional scholars Reva Siegel (Yale Law School), Serena Mayeri (the University of Pennsylvania Carey Law School), and Melissa Murray (New York University School of Law) may be of interest to readers, as it draws on "equality challenges to abortion bans [that] preceded Roe."

Equal Protection in Dobbs and Beyond: How States Protect Life Inside and Outside of the Abortion Context 

In the leaked draft of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, Justice Samuel Alito dismissed the Equal Protection Clause as an alternative ground of the abortion right, citing an amicus brief in which we advanced that argument. In dicta, Justice Alito claimed that precedents foreclosed the brief’s arguments (pp. 10-11).

Justice Alito did not address a single equal protection case or argument on which the brief relied. Instead, he cited Geduldig v. Aiello, a 1974 case decided before the Court extended heightened scrutiny to sex-based state action—a case our brief shows has been superseded by United States v. Virginia and Nevada Department of Human Resources v. Hibbs. Justice Alito’s claim to address equal protection precedents without discussing any of these decisions suggests an unwillingness to recognize the last half century of sex equality law—a spirit that finds many forms of expression in the opinion’s due process analysis.

This Essay, written before Justice Alito’s draft leaked, explains the brief’s equal protection arguments for abortion rights, and shows how these equality-based arguments open up crucial conversations that extend far beyond abortion.

* * *

Equality challenges to abortion bans preceded Roe, and will continue long after Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization, however the Court rules in that case. In this Essay we discuss our amicus brief in Dobbs, demonstrating that Mississippi’s ban on abortions after 15 weeks violates the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause.

Our brief shows how the canonical equal protection cases United States v. Virginia and Department of Human Resources v. Hibbs extend to the regulation of pregnancy, providing an independent constitutional basis for abortion rights. Abortion bans classify by sex. Equal protection requires the government to explain why group-based rather than facially-neutral regulations best serve its ends, especially when the challenged laws perpetuate historic forms of group-based harm. As we show, Mississippi decided to ban abortion, choosing sex-based and coercive means to protect health and life; at the same time the state consistently refused to enact safety-net policies that offered inclusive, noncoercive means to achieve the same health- and life-protective ends.

Our brief asks: Could the state have pursued these same life- and health-protective ends with more inclusive, less coercive strategies? This inquiry has ramifications in courts, in legislatures, and in the court of public opinion. Equal protection focuses the inquiry on how gender, race, and class may distort decisions about protecting life and health, within and outside the abortion context. The equal protection argument can play a role in congressional and executive enforcement of constitutional rights, in the enforcement of equality provisions of state constitutions, and in ongoing debate about proper shape of family life in our constitutional democracy. Equal protection may also have the power to forge new coalitions as it asks hard questions about the kinds of laws that protect the health and life of future generations and that help families flourish. 

The essay is forthcoming in Volume 43 of the Columbia Journal of Gender and Law (2023) and is available for download here, at SSRN.

-- Karen Tani

Legal History Reviewed in the JSH

We were grateful to have our attention drawn to the many book reviews in the May 2022 issue (88:2) of the Journal of Southern History of interest to legal historians.  These include:

The Cabinet: George Washington and the Creation of an American Institution by Lindsay M. Chervinsky
Ari Helo

Irreconcilable Founders: Spencer Roane, John Marshall, and the Nature of America's Constitutional Republic by David Johnson
J. Charles Waldrup

At the Threshold of Liberty: Women, Slavery, and Shifting Identities in Washington, D.C. by Tamika Y. Nunley
Elizabeth Wood

Jim Crow in North Carolina: The Legislative Program from 1865 to 1920 by Richard A. Paschal
Abel A. Bartley

Reconstruction Politics in a Deep South State, Alabama, 1865-1874 by William Warren Rogers Jr.
Bertis D. English

A Question of Freedom: The Families Who Challenged Slavery from the Nation's Founding to the Civil War by William G. Thomas III
Alice L. Baumgartner

Forgotten Legacy: William McKinley, George Henry White, and the Struggle for Black Equality by Benjamin R. Justesen
Adam Burns

Threatening Property: Race, Class, and Campaigns to Legislate Jim Crow Neighborhoods by Elizabeth A. Herbin-Triant
Freddie L. Parker

The 1921 Tulsa Race Massacre: A Photographic History by Karlos K. Hill
Ben Davidson

Alabama Justice: The Cases and Faces That Changed a Nation by Steven P. Brown
Ian J. Drake

The Movement: The African American Struggle for Civil Rights by Thomas C. Holt
Raymond Arsenault

Civil Rights in America: A History by Christopher W. Schmidt
Adam Lee Cilli